Shannon Vallor
banner
shannonvallor.bsky.social
Shannon Vallor
@shannonvallor.bsky.social

Philosopher/AI Ethicist at Univ of Edinburgh, co-Director @technomoralfutures.bsky.social and BRAID @braiduk.bsky.social, author of Technology and the Virtues (2016) and The AI Mirror (2024). Views my own. Humble servant to Carol and Puffin. .. more

Shannon Vallor is an American philosopher of technology. She is the Baillie Gifford Chair in the Ethics of Data and Artificial Intelligence at the Edinburgh Futures Institute. She previously taught at Santa Clara University in Santa Clara, California where she was the Regis and Dianne McKenna Professor of Philosophy and William J. Rewak, S.J. Professor at SCU. .. more

Neuroscience 30%
Computer science 22%

Reposted by Shannon Vallor

At the current rate, by the end of the year the UK will go through over 50 prime ministers, each one worse than the last, until the last one is literally just Gollum devouring raw fish in an abandoned coal mine under Wales. He will also be in the Epstein files.

I have a cat who routinely sticks her whole face in my water glass and now I have a dog who can already leap vertically 4x her height

I am resigned to never again enjoy a snack in my home in peace

omg her face Robin
This really is the epitome of trending Bluesky topics. Something British, sportsball, "political outrage" (can't phrase it better than that), something artsy fartsy, NERDS!)

Same - it was Y1 philosophy that humbled me too, and it took a couple of years to get past the sting and fall back in love with it.

Reposted by Shannon Vallor

Halt and Catch Fire Syllabus by @ashleyblewer.com
Incredible!

Reposted by Shannon Vallor

Bottom view of a cat that has fallen asleep on a glass table.

After getting through high school on zero effort, showing up to 7am AP classes on a pot of diner coffee after being out all night, my first semester of college was like the Road Runner hitting the canyon wall painted as a tunnel. Took a year to pick myself up and learn to actually work
Alright, where are my gifted kids at? You were smart and you never had to study and then you went to college and suddenly had to learn a new skillset overnight, that everybody else had years to learn, or flame out spectacularly?

That’s what talent is like.
In my experience, talent is a *detriment* to learning.

I didn't have to practice early on so I *didn't know how*. I didn't start to learn how to practice until my 30s! (When much of my life was taken up with parenting, so I didn't have time!)

I didn't start to improve as a musician until my 40s!

Thread
An observation I've been thinking about:

Around 2020, we were told that US political & corporate elites had been gripped by "wokeness" & thus become obsessed with climate change & diversity. This wokeness was alleged to be so severe & monomaniacal that it threatened the entire culture & economy.

Reposted by Shannon Vallor

An observation I've been thinking about:

Around 2020, we were told that US political & corporate elites had been gripped by "wokeness" & thus become obsessed with climate change & diversity. This wokeness was alleged to be so severe & monomaniacal that it threatened the entire culture & economy.

Reposted by Shannon Vallor

Alright, where are my gifted kids at? You were smart and you never had to study and then you went to college and suddenly had to learn a new skillset overnight, that everybody else had years to learn, or flame out spectacularly?

That’s what talent is like.
In my experience, talent is a *detriment* to learning.

I didn't have to practice early on so I *didn't know how*. I didn't start to learn how to practice until my 30s! (When much of my life was taken up with parenting, so I didn't have time!)

I didn't start to improve as a musician until my 40s!
I'm going to say this again in case you haven't heard this one: I was a talented writer and it did *nothing whatsoever* because I hadn't put in the work, and I put in the work for ten years (subtracting the bit where I had to quit for my mental health) to write Witchmark

talent alone could *never*

right??

There’s so much I have to say about this, much of which is in my book. But the lack of critical questioning and the last two sentences of this article encapsulate everything wrong with tech journalism:

“Like it or not, however, we’re strapped in for the ride. At least Anthropic has a plan”
The Only Thing Standing Between Humanity and AI Apocalypse Is … Claude?
As AI systems grow more powerful, Anthropic’s resident philosopher says the startup is betting Claude itself can learn the wisdom needed to avoid disaster.
www.wired.com

That’s why I’m most worried about this effect on public understanding, given the rapid substitution of LLMs for vetted, current research, or even popular science magazines, which used to be the curious layperson’s go-to source. Most laypeople will now just ask AI, without sophisticated prompting.
Would be interesting to compare the results on more recent models - but this problem won’t go away. LLMs are always going to be extrapolating from what has already, and often, been thought, which is why they aren’t windows to the future but anchors to the past.
Neat demonstration of how artificial so-called intelligence is taking us backwards.

"ChatGPT produced content most consistent with the 1960s and DALL-E 3 in the late 1980s and early '90s."

#AI - see @shannonvallor.bsky.social's work for important thinking on this
phys.org/news/2026-02...
New study uses Neanderthals to demonstrate gap between generative AI and scholarly knowledge
Technological advances over the past four decades have turned mobile devices and computers into the world's largest library, where information is just a tap away. Phones, laptops, tablets, smartwatche...
phys.org
Trump job approval rating by news platform

🟢 Twitter/X: +9
🔴 Facebook: -7
🔴 Cable TV: -10
🔴 Podcasts/YouTube: -14
🔴 Local TV: -17
🔴 Instagram: -21
🔴 Broadcast TV: -28
🔴 TikTok: -28
🔴 Newspapers/news sites: -33
🔴 Reddit: -40

www.theargumentmag.com/p/twitter-is...

I struggle to find a more logical explanation
Are we in hell?
There's something very important in this from @alondra.bsky.social about how a government of bosses understands its relationship to AI: as a means to avoid preexisting, even nominal, deference to popular deliberation or expert consultation. www.science.org/doi/10.1126/...

Reposted by Shannon Vallor

Are we in hell?
"That is a truly fascist idea, the idea of outsourcing thinking....power is in our ability to think with each other"

Klein on the "AI for climate" crap and how to weave a better story:

www.themaybe.org/reframing-im...

@naomiaklein.bsky.social
@themaybe.org
@alixdunn.com
Good news - we have a new ERC-funded 4-year PhD Studentship at the University of Edinburgh, based in Philosophy and our Centre @technomoralfutures.bsky.social, supervised by Dr Emily Sullivan; the project applies philosophy of science to assessing ML's epistemic & social value. Apply by 16 March!
ERC PhD studentship: The Ethics and Philosophy of Science of Machine Learning | Scholarships and Student Funding | Student Administration
This is a four-year ERC funded PhD studentship (starting in September 2026).
registryservices.ed.ac.uk
Using tech to manufacture BS anti-vax claims

Such a terrible day for journalism.

And for democracy, for it does in fact die in darkness.

Where are the wealthy defenders of a free and open society, charging in to fund real reporting in America? [sound of crickets]
My story on Elon Musk cutting safeguards at xAI is on the front page of today's @washingtonpost.com. I’m also among 100’s of reporters laid off. I absolutely loved my job my brilliant coworkers & the thrill of reporting @ the center of forces upending the world: AI & Silicon Valley’s political power

Your work is vital, and I am so angry about this. For you, but even more so for the rest of us that need your reporting.

Reposted by Shannon Vallor

As of 2025, the US has taken a U-turn on climate progress, and it is only going to get worse.
My story on Elon Musk cutting safeguards at xAI is on the front page of today's @washingtonpost.com. I’m also among 100’s of reporters laid off. I absolutely loved my job my brilliant coworkers & the thrill of reporting @ the center of forces upending the world: AI & Silicon Valley’s political power
ohhh ‘democracy dies in darkness’ was aspirational