Bruce Bradbury
brucebradbury.bsky.social
Bruce Bradbury
@brucebradbury.bsky.social

An Australian economist writing on social and economic policy and outcomes.
https://www.unsw.edu.au/staff/bruce-bradbury

Economics 30%
Education 20%

How can social protection policies help? One partial answer is to provide greater support for people with moderate impairments. In Australia, increasing JobSeeker allowance, relaxing income tests, relaxing job search requirements - in other words moving towards a UBI.

AI might not take our manual jobs. But can our ageing bodies handle it? www.nytimes.com/2025/12/28/o...
Opinion | When A.I. Took My Job, I Bought a Chain Saw
www.nytimes.com

Males get more free time. (The hours add up to over 24, because it restricts to those who participate in the activity. But the gender gap persists when averaged over all). www.abs.gov.au/statistics/p... #ABS
I try to avoid linking to Substacks but this essay is FASCINATING
I'm Kenyan. I Don't Write Like ChatGPT. ChatGPT Writes Like Me.
I'm calm. I'm calm. I promise.
marcusolang.substack.com

Going to be one of the most downloaded papers ever!

"parallel trends in the log of an outcome variable precludes parallel trends in levels. The paper closes with an examination of a valiant recent attempt to wriggle out of this troubling functional-form constraint" Looking forward to reading.
This looks like a must-read for diff-in-diffs folks.

www.nber.org/papers/w34550
This looks like a must-read for diff-in-diffs folks.

www.nber.org/papers/w34550

As one of the substack responders said, this introduces questions about moral behaviour which researchers are nervous about. Also, are some people with CD very economically successful? Even so, I agree with your implied conclusion that we shouldn't be ignoring this.

"AI is the asbestos in the walls of our technological society, stuffed there with wild abandon by a finance sector and tech monopolists run amok. We will be excavating it for a generation or more."
pluralistic.net/2025/12/05/p...
Pluralistic: The Reverse-Centaur’s Guide to Criticizing AI (05 Dec 2025) – Pluralistic: Daily links from Cory Doctorow
pluralistic.net
Big new blogpost!

My guide to data visualization, which includes a very long table of contents, tons of charts, and more.

--> Why data visualization matters and how to make charts more effective, clear, transparent, and sometimes, beautiful.
www.scientificdiscovery.dev/p/salonis-gu...

"We show that, in finite samples, first-differencing and novel rolling estimators can offer researchers a practical alternative to the fixed effects estimator"
"On the (Mis) Use of the Fixed Effects Estimator"

(by @dlmillimet.bsky.social and Marc F. Bellemare)

published in the Oxford Bulletin of Economics & Statistics.

onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/...
On the (Mis) Use of the Fixed Effects Estimator
Data that span multiple units and time periods allow controlling for time-invariant heterogeneity correlated with the covariates. While researchers can do this in different ways, the fixed effects es....
onlinelibrary.wiley.com
One observation about this interesting new paper on the credibility revolution in political science journal articles is that all (?) of its interesting findings are correlational, not causal

osf.io/preprints/so...

So, if there is a substantial +ve causal relationship between x and y (as identified by a properly specified instrument), but the OLS is small, this could be because some unobserved confounder has a +ve impact on x but -ve on y (or vice versa).

That's good. But in my haste, I scrambled my explanation. The 2SLS is the ratio of the reduced form y=f(Instrument) to the first stage x=f(Instrument). So, 2SLS is larger for weaker first stage. The OLS could be larger or smaller depending on the relationship with unobserved vars.

However, if the gap between 2SLS and OLS is large, it means the first stage is weak. In this case estimates can be biased. Search for literature on 'weak instruments'.

Normally the 2SLS will be larger than the OLS. Consider the case of a random experiment, but using 2SLS to correct for incomplete compliance. The OLS will be the intention to treat estimate, and the 2SLS inflates this to remove the downward bias due to noncompliance. /2

Evaluating machine learning procedures using 120 cases? Nonsense. The infographic is the best part of the paper.

Reposted by Bruce Bradbury

New from my phd student @joshgoddard98.bsky.social: he shows, using many election and panel studies across the advanced democracies, that housing status has replaced occupational class as a key predictor of voting. Class voting is now about assets, not income www.sciencedirect.com/science/arti...
Housing and electoral behaviour: The changing face of class voting in advanced democracies
Scholarship on the relationship between social structure and electoral behaviour has traditionally operationalised voters’ economic or class situation…
www.sciencedirect.com

One in 20 Australian Indigenous adult men are in jail. (original source: www.abs.gov.au/statistics/p...)
The latest corrective services data is out today, and it points a horrific picture of the systemic racism in our judicial system #PointLive
live.thepoint.com.au

Though causality runs in both directions - "Taken together, these results point to a simple but important insight: the entry period into the [Australian] NDIS is a time when caring responsibilities increase, not fall. "
e61.in/navigating-t...
Navigating the NDIS may increase caring responsibilities in the early years – e61 INSTITUTE
e61.in

Reposted by Bruce Bradbury

The latest corrective services data is out today, and it points a horrific picture of the systemic racism in our judicial system #PointLive
live.thepoint.com.au

So, call "relative poverty" a measure of inequality if you want, but it is an indicator that has a much more specific moral and political meaning than other more general inequality indicators.

For example, many countries set official "absolute" poverty lines which change over time in line with prices rather than national income. However, the lines set in rich countries are always much higher than the lines set in poor countries. /4

"Unacceptable" is a political concept that will vary depending on the resources available in any given country. It reflects both the ability of a country to do something about it, as well as a view that the poor should not have a living standard that is well below the norm for their society. /3

My take: While a poverty measure based on low consumption provides useful information, the relative framework is also important. In this context, I think of a poverty line as a threshold below which people have an "unacceptably low level of consumption". /2

Lawrence Eppard thinks he was wrong about poverty. I think he was right in the first place. Discussion on The Temple of Sociology substack. templeofsociology.substack.com/p/absolute-v...
Absolute vs. Relative Poverty in Social Science
A New Article on Relative Poverty by Lawrence Eppard
templeofsociology.substack.com

Reposted by Bruce Bradbury

The Economist makes a good point in warning that, at some point, high may be too high, and that we should look beyond the effects on employment. But, I don’t think there is (yet) any consensus that we reached the maximum as they seem to imply in their piece.
As governments champion a consensus on wage floors, scholars are getting cold feet. A growing body of research suggests that they can degrade jobs, even if they don’t destroy them
Why governments should stop raising the minimum wage
After a decade of rises, there are now far better tools for fighting poverty
econ.st
This is terrifying.

"[AI agents] can... infer a researcher's latent hypotheses and produce data that artificially confirms them."

...

"We can no longer trust that survey responses are coming from real people" -@seanjwestwood.bsky.social