Lawrence Freedman
ldfreedman.bsky.social
Lawrence Freedman
@ldfreedman.bsky.social

Emeritus Professor of War Studies King's College London. Latest Book Command: The Politics of Military Operations from Korea to Ukraine. Substack Comment is Freed https://samf.substack.com/

Sir Lawrence David Freedman, is a British academic, historian and author specialising in foreign policy, international relations and strategy. He has been described as the "dean of British strategic studies" and was a member of the Iraq Inquiry. He is an Emeritus Professor of War Studies at King's College London. .. more

Political science 82%
Sociology 6%

He doesn’t think things through. I suspect it reflects his own frustration with his options, and an instinctive reach for tariffs. I’m guessing Steve Miller was instrumental.

Reposted by Lawrence Freedman

New post just out:

"Power to the People"

Today we have a guest post from @jamestplunkett.bsky.social on how Labour can counter the "Britain is Broken" narrative by investing in civic life and giving people more control over their community.

(Free to read)

open.substack.com/pub/samf/p/p...
Power to the People
How Labour can restore civic life and counter the "Britain is broken" narrative
open.substack.com

Greenland was Trump’s idea. I suspect Miller was in the office today.

If Congress and courts go along with this you are right but at the moment we are reacting to a post on social media.

Ha. I’ll do full penance if I’m wrong.

Yep

He is a bully and doesn’t like to be resisted. But he also doesn’t like to be seen to fail.

Its Trump, Vance and Miller. Very little support in Congress.
All key European leaders now said they won’t go along with this. So if the objective was coercion it has already failed. (This is not a US miscalculation- its a very Trumpian one).
Keir Starmer often takes 2-3 days to issue very mild criticism of US actions. This is both direct and issued fast.

I think there is a serious risk that the US miscalculated quite what a big deal the Greenland thing is to Europe (and in Europe).
NEW - Starmer says US "completely wrong" in threatening tariffs over Greenland

No. I don’t think these tariffs will be implemented because of the pushback.

Quite possible. It should give some urgency to getting out their ruling.

We have had quick and appropriate responses from E3 and others saying they can’t and won’t hand over Greenland. So we already know coercion of this sort won’t work. The next step is for EU and UK to start working out forms of retaliation if he does go ahead - but I wouldn’t assume he will.

He said he was running Venezuela and he isn’t. He said he was going to take military action against Iran and he didn’t. He was going to take Greenland by force and he can see why that might look bad. So now he bullies. He doesn’t have an indomitable will.

I think you’ll find Stephen Miller was in office today.

I agree. I’m saying push back and not assume done deal.

Not counting on anything - but in hearings they were sceptical. Could pronounce on Tuesday

We should take it seriously and push back. Not assume that it is now fixed. His tariffs policy has been all over the place.
Keir Starmer often takes 2-3 days to issue very mild criticism of US actions. This is both direct and issued fast.

I think there is a serious risk that the US miscalculated quite what a big deal the Greenland thing is to Europe (and in Europe).
NEW - Starmer says US "completely wrong" in threatening tariffs over Greenland
We should know by now not to respond to one of Trump’s weekend posts as a definitive statement of policy. The content is as outrageous as it is absurd. For that reason there will be strong pushback from markets, Congress, perhaps Supreme Court as well as European governments.
Trump says he'll impose a 10% tariff (rising to 25% in June) on Denmark, Norway, Sweden, France, Germany, the UK, the Netherlands and Finland, because they've sent people to Greenland, until the US can buy Greenland.

On 16 January 1979 the Shah fled Iran for good. Now the question is how long will the regime that replaced him last. In this post I compare the situation 1979 revolution to the one currently underway. (£/free trial), open.substack.com/pub/samf/p/r...?
Revolution in Iran : Now and Then
Why the regime is doomed
open.substack.com
From the post I wrote about Reform vs. the Tories last September.

samf.substack.com/p/last-rites

New post from Sam identifies areas where peoples interactions with the state are frustrating and which governments should be able to fix without great expense. If they can sort out driving license applications why not driving tests? (£/free trial) samf.substack.com/p/troublesho...
Troubleshooters
How to get people believing in the state again
samf.substack.com

As it says £ or free trial.

New post on how Trump is failing to run Venezuela even as he moves on to Greenland. How does one deal with a president that regularly makes untrue assertions and delusional boasts that affect real places and people? (£/free trial), open.substack.com/pub/samf/p/f...?
From Venezuela to Greenland
On the challenges of managing Trump
open.substack.com
Oops.

“US citizens in Venezuela should leave the country immediately…

“There are reports of groups of armed militias, known as colectivos, setting up roadblocks and searching vehicles for evidence of US citizenship or support for the United States.”