Felicity Callard

@felicitycallard.bsky.social

2.4K followers 1.5K following 840 posts

Geographies & histories of what we have come to call “mental health” | the university | daydreams & fantasies | Freud | Marx

Editor, History of the Human Sciences @histhum.bsky.social

Videos

Psychology 36%

Philosophy 17%

Posts Replies Media Videos

Pinned

Felicity Callard @felicitycallard.bsky.social · 6d

I wrote on psychic life and Palestinian resistance

– to ensure more people read Abdaljawad Omar @hamayel.bsky.social.

www.cambridge.org/core/journal...

For the Palestinian people, psychic life is just as much a site of struggle for liberation as social life. Palestinians are persistently refused psychological amplitude, characteristics easily granted to those who are never worried they might fall out of what is constituted as the category of the human. Abdaljawad Omar’s writings in English published since October 7, 2023 (as well as writings by other Palestinians, other Arabs, and those of Palestinian descent) offer means of understanding material resistance in relation to the terrain of the psyche. Omar offers distinctive accounts of mourning, loss, and ruins, as well as of how settler colonialism reorganizes experiences of time and relations between past, present, and future. The article reads Omar’s writings against other accounts of mourning and of psychic phenomena that are indebted to psychoanalysis. Omar’s analyses of Palestinians’ resistance to unfreedom and annihilation open up other ways of understanding the psychic vicissitudes of those who suffer, grieve, and struggle to exit a colonial condition characterized by the colonizer’s repeated attempts to break psychic worlds as well as erase bodily life. Understandings of psychic life that do justice to how Palestine is redrawing the world are central to the work of ‘cracking history open’.

Felicity Callard @felicitycallard.bsky.social · 7h

We would love for @jaytoddgla.bsky.social’s and my critical response to be read widely, given the Sullivan Review’s potential for far-reaching implications across the social and health sciences — and indeed well beyond the academy

TIBG @tibg.bsky.social · 11h

New Intervention in TIBG:

'A critical response to the UK's "Sullivan Review" into sex and gender in research and data' by @jaytoddgla.bsky.social & @felicitycallard.bsky.social

doi.org/10.1111/tran...

Screenshot of an intervention abstract in Transactions by Jay JD Todd & Felicity Callard (2026) entitled: 'A Critical Response to the UK's ‘Sullivan Review’ Into Sex and Gender in Research and Data' with a red banner at the top.

This intervention argues that the UK Government-commissioned independent review of data, statistics and research on sex and gender (the ‘Sullivan Review’) implicitly promotes the erasure of trans and gender diverse people from research and data collection protocols and carries worrying implications for the inclusion of trans people within UK institutions and for critical social science research. Set in a context where trans and gender diverse people's rights are being rolled back in the United Kingdom and elsewhere, the Review attempts to install a singular model of binary, immutable, ‘biological’ sex as incontrovertible across data gathering on sex and gender across public bodies including government, universities, the health service and research organisations. It does so via appeals to science and to ‘clarity’, and by proposing to limit or even in certain cases remove default ethical review processes. The intervention argues that the Review can be situated within broader attempts to erase critical inquiry into the complex, intersectional production of social categories including sex, gender and sexuality, as well as inquiries that extend what ethical principles and governance involve. In sum, we contend that the Review carries deleterious consequences for geography and other social scientific disciplines and call upon scholars to refuse its vision and implications.

Felicity Callard @felicitycallard.bsky.social · 8h

Many university researchers (& many social scientists) have no idea that the 'Sullivan Review' (named after its lead author, sociologist Sullivan) exists nor of its potential potency.

@jaytoddgla.bsky.social and I wanted to set the Review in context

rgs-ibg.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/...

In selecting Sullivan, the commissioners chose an advisory group member of Sex Matters, which understands sex as binary, ‘real, immutable and important’ (what it calls ‘objective reality’) and claims, in contrast, ‘gender identity’ as a determination of whether ‘someone is male or female (or both or neither)’ is merely a ‘strongly held and erroneous personal feeling’ (Sex Matters 2024). Prior to selection, Sullivan had made clear she disagreed with research not conceptualising sex as binary and immutable (e.g., Sullivan 2020). While SR1 does not use the phrase ‘gender critical’ to describe its framework, it is allied—through its lead author, terminologies and recommendations—with those self-identifying as ‘gender critical’ feminists. It includes, for example, terms such as ‘adult human female’ (SR1, 11, 43) which some scholars have recognised as an ‘anti-transgender dogwhistle’ (Duffy 2025). ‘Gender critical’ feminism has been analysed by other feminist and queer scholars as part of a broader anti-gender movement (Butler 2025), gender conservatism (S. Ahmed 2021) and a manifestation of ‘postfascist feminism’ (Bassi and LaFleur 2022).2 These scholars have demonstrated that this movement's arguments are, as in Bassi and LaFleur's (2022, 317) words, ‘genealogically coherent with multiple conservative moral panics and resilient fascist tropes’. Meanwhile, the Lemkin Institute for Genocide Prevention (2025a, n.p.) has stated that ‘the beliefs held by the gender critical movement overlap significantly with those held by various authoritarian governments and fascist political parties the world over’.

Reposted by Felicity Callard

Ruth Pearce @notrightruth.bsky.social · 10h

I'm glad Dr Todd and Prof Callard remind us right at the start of their article that the Sullivan Review was commissioned as part of the Conservative Party's "Kicking Woke Ideology Out of Science" programme. A strong and stable grounding for policy-based evidence-making.

Badly-designed poster featuring the slogans "Long term decisions for a brighter future", and "Kicking woke ideology out of science". There are also some swirling red, white, and blue ribbons, and some jars with colourful liquids.

Reposted by Katharine Hayhoe, Daniela Gabor, Juan Cole , and 2 more Katharine Hayhoe, Daniela Gabor, Juan Cole, Robin Celikates, Felicity Callard

Jack Mirkinson @jackmirkinson.bsky.social · 11h

Media coverage of Gaza has plummeted. So today on @thenation.com, we're doing something pretty special: we're only running pieces by people in and from Gaza.

We're calling it "A Day for Gaza." You can find links to all of the incredible pieces here. Please read! www.thenation.com/article/worl...

A Day for Gaza

Today, The Nation is turning over its website exclusively to stories from Gaza and its people. This is why.

www.thenation.com

Reposted by Felicity Callard

TIBG @tibg.bsky.social · 11h

Felicity Callard @felicitycallard.bsky.social · 11h

Wasn't necessarily expecting to get our research covered in Attitude Mag but I'm so glad @attitudemag.bsky.social has:

"We are calling upon researchers across the UK to reject the recommendations of the Sullivan Review," says Dr Jay Todd @jaytoddgla.bsky.social"
www.attitude.co.uk/news/uk-gove...

UK Government review on sex and gender slammed by professionals for wrongly portraying trans identities

Researchers have warned that the UK Government’s review on sex and gender risks harming studies relating to trans identities.

www.attitude.co.uk

Felicity Callard @felicitycallard.bsky.social · 12h

Thank you for posting about our paper @paisleycurrah.com. Your writings have been central to our thinking through our critique of the Sullivan Review.

Felicity Callard @felicitycallard.bsky.social · 14h

For US-based friends: Jay's @jaytoddgla.bsky.social & my critical response to UK 'Sullivan Review' shows its international reach:

Already used by Trump administration to secure commitment to 'sex-based language' & excise 'gender' & 'gender identity' rgs-ibg.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/...

SR1 is already having impact internationally. For example, it is cited authoritatively in Trump administration reports, including on ‘Pediatric Gender Dysphoria’, which moves against gender-affirming care for transgender children. There, SR1 bolsters that report's excision of the terms ‘gender’ and ‘gender identity’ and its commitment to biological, ‘sex-based language’ (US Department of Health and Human Services 2025, 39-40). SR1, we argue, must be seen as contributing to reactionary interventions that erase the realities and constrict the socio-spatial worlds of trans adults and children (Gill-Peterson 2018).

Felicity Callard @felicitycallard.bsky.social · 15h

U Glasgow has covered Jay Todd's @jaytoddgla.bsky.social & my critical paper on the 'Sullivan Review' rgs-ibg.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/...

Many social scientists whom Jay & I talk to are (still) unaware of the Sullivan Review and its potential implications. Our paper aims to change this

UofGNews @uofgnews.bsky.social · 16h

Recommendations from the Sullivan Review could undermine the quality of public institutions’ research, erode academic freedom, and threaten the rights of trans and gender diverse people if widely adopted, @uofgges.bsky.social researchers have warned.

Read more here: www.gla.ac.uk/news/headlin...

Reposted by Felicity Callard

UofGNews @uofgnews.bsky.social · 16h

Felicity Callard @felicitycallard.bsky.social · 16h

I never post a link to the THE but the THE has covered Jay Todd's @jaytoddgla.bsky.social and my paper with the headline, 'Trans research "at risk" if data collection guidance adopted'

rgs-ibg.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/...

Trans research ‘at risk’ if data collection guidance adopted
Response to Sullivan Review argues recommendations could hit quality of findings and impinge on academic freedom

Published on February 3, 2026
Last updated February 3, 2026
Patrick Jack
Twitter: @paddywjack

The recommendations of a review into how sex and gender data is collected could damage the quality of public research and is part of wider efforts to erase trans people from statistics, a new paper has argued.

Felicity Callard @felicitycallard.bsky.social · 16h

(Ended up serendipitously publishing 2 things very important to me almost simultaneously – one on Palestinian resistance, and one in the service of trans liberation – and I can almost feel the anxious brush of moving fingers too worried to press a like button on either)

Reposted by John Hogan

Felicity Callard @felicitycallard.bsky.social · 17h

Jay Todd @jaytoddgla.bsky.social and I have published today in @tibg.bsky.social a critical response to the UK Government-commissioned "Sullivan Review" of sex and gender in data and research collection

rgs-ibg.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/...

ABSTRACT
This intervention argues that the UK Government-commissioned independent review of data, statistics and research on sex and gender (the ‘Sullivan Review’) implicitly promotes the erasure of trans and gender diverse people from research and data collection protocols and carries worrying implications for the inclusion of trans people within UK institutions and for critical social science research. Set in a context where trans and gender diverse people's rights are being rolled back in the United Kingdom and elsewhere, the Review attempts to install a singular model of binary, immutable, ‘biological’ sex as incontrovertible across data gathering on sex and gender across public bodies including government, universities, the health service and research organisations. It does so via appeals to science and to ‘clarity’, and by proposing to limit or even in certain cases remove default ethical review processes. The intervention argues that the Review can be situated within broader attempts to erase critical inquiry into the complex, intersectional production of social categories including sex, gender and sexuality, as well as inquiries that extend what ethical principles and governance involve. In sum, we contend that the Review carries deleterious consequences for geography and other social scientific disciplines and call upon scholars to refuse its vision and implications.

Reposted by Steven French, Catherine Baker, Malcolm MacLean , and 2 more Steven French, Catherine Baker, Malcolm MacLean, Felicity Callard, John Hogan

Jay Todd 🏳️‍⚧️ @jaytoddgla.bsky.social · 17h

📣 Today @felicitycallard.bsky.social and I have published the first peer-reviewed response to the 'Sullivan Review' of research and data on sex and gender.

doi.org/10.1111/tran...

The Review could threaten trans rights and inclusion, erode academic freedom, and undermine research quality.

Graphic reading 'the UK Government-commissioned 'Sullivan Review' of sex and gender in data and research collection threatens British research and trans inclusion. Here's why.'

Reposted by Felicity Callard

The National @scotnational.bsky.social · 17h

NEW: A UK Government review on sex and gender could 'undermine' scientific research and 'erode academic freedom', researchers have warned

UK Government sex and gender review 'harmful to scientific research', study warns

www.thenational.scot

Reposted by Felicity Callard

Dr Kevin Guyan @kevinguyan.bsky.social · 17h

📢 New peer-reviewed academic response to the Sullivan Review into sex and gender in research and data.

@jaytoddgla.bsky.social and @felicitycallard.bsky.social have published a critical response to the Sullivan Review.

doi.org/10.1111/tran...

Screen grab of front page for article: A Critical Response to the UK's ‘Sullivan Review’ Into Sex and Gender in Research and Data

Felicity Callard @felicitycallard.bsky.social · 18h

Going to go and have a read

Felicity Callard @felicitycallard.bsky.social · 18h

“the real thing”! Where in the book does this appear?

Felicity Callard @felicitycallard.bsky.social · 19h

Thank you, that is very kind of you

Felicity Callard @felicitycallard.bsky.social · 19h

When people would ask in the last couple of years why I would choose to cross the US border, I said I love my uncle very much and I want to see him while he is still here bsky.app/profile/feli...

Felicity Callard @felicitycallard.bsky.social · 1d

By those whom we love are we made. That education and practices of pedagogy have come to have such a central place in my life is unimaginable without my dear uncle, Andrew Carruthers Garrod. I miss you fas.dartmouth.edu/news/2026/02...

Remembering Andrew Garrod, Visionary Educator and Humanitarian | Faculty of Arts and Sciences

The professor of education emeritus dedicated his career to amplifying student voices and bridging cultural divides.

fas.dartmouth.edu

Felicity Callard @felicitycallard.bsky.social · 1d

Remembering Andrew Garrod, Visionary Educator and Humanitarian | Faculty of Arts and Sciences

The professor of education emeritus dedicated his career to amplifying student voices and bridging cultural divides.

fas.dartmouth.edu

Reposted by Valerie Mueller, Felicity Callard, Keith Lilley , and 5 more Valerie Mueller, Felicity Callard, Keith Lilley, Nazita Lajevardi, Jason Dittmer, Katherine Brickell, Ian Bruff, Dan Immergluck

Brett Christophers @brettchristophers.bsky.social · 1d

We're recruiting 2 PhD candidates in human geography here in Uppsala, one position focused on urban/housing issues and one in political ecology.

Please spread the word/repost etc. Being a PhD student in Sweden is a good gig.

2 PhD student positions in Human Geography - Uppsala University

2 PhD student positions in Human Geography, Department of Human Geography, Uppsala University

www.uu.se

Reposted by Roger Luckhurst, Felicity Callard

Andrew McGettigan @amcgettigan.bsky.social · 1d

Mandelson commissioned the Browne review which led to the current mess in English HE ...

Felicity Callard @felicitycallard.bsky.social · 1d

I look forward to reading this, Nick

Reposted by Will Jennings, Dave O’Brien, Lesley A. Hall , and 2 more Will Jennings, Dave O’Brien, Lesley A. Hall, Felicity Callard, Peter Allen

Nick Clarke @nickclarkegeo.bsky.social · 1d

New paper on luck, geography, and politics

www.sciencedirect.com/science/arti...

Right place, right time: Luck, geography, and politics

On 12th May 2020, Mass Observation collected c5,000 diaries from people across the UK. Many of these diaries mention luck and many of these luck stori…

www.sciencedirect.com

Felicity Callard @felicitycallard.bsky.social · 2d

I remember exactly where I was, how burnt the taste in my mouth, when I read Sarah Aziza's "Doomsday Diaries
October 7–17, 2023" in @thebaffler.com on 18 October, 2023

thebaffler.com/latest/dooms...

Doomsday Diaries | Sarah Aziza

What does it feel like to stand at the edge of annihilation?

thebaffler.com

Reposted by John Hogan

Felicity Callard @felicitycallard.bsky.social · 2d

Sarah Aziza's writing is always wrenching, indispensable

"We will never be after Gaza. However we choose to proceed, her blood is a sacred stain that will outlast all of us"

Reposted by Felicity Callard, John Hogan

Felicity Callard @felicitycallard.bsky.social · 2d

That passage in Freud has been living inside and gnawing at me for decades (as someone born in London and someone trained as a geographer) and it was only when I read Abdaljawad Omar’s essay, “Can the Palestinian mourn?” that I knew how I needed to write about it

Felicity Callard @felicitycallard.bsky.social · 2d

Thank you so much for reading Yasmin and for writing this

Add to Home Screen

Light up
your news

Add to Home Screen

Light upyour news

Sign in to Lightnews

Sign up to start reading

Connect Bluesky

Connect with Bluesky

Light up
your news