JCRE
banner
jcre.bsky.social
JCRE
@jcre.bsky.social

Journal of Comments and Replications in Economics
https://www.jcr-econ.org/ hosted at @zbw-leibniz.bsky.social‬. Supported by @jherzstiftung.bsky.social
Editors: W. Robert Reed, @mariannesaam.bsky.social, Dennis Wesselbaum, @chuanliu.bsky.social .. more

Economics 71%
Sociology 9%

Rogowski et al. (2022) show that historical postal networks boosted economic development across countries and within the US.
The replication study reproduced all results — the findings are broadly robust, though somewhat sensitive to spatial trends. #Replication #Economics #OpenScience

Reposted by Jörg Peters

New in JCRE: “Public Infrastructure and Economic Development: Evidence from Postal Systems A Replication Study of Rogowski et al. (American Journal of Political Science, 2022) by @florianneubauer.bsky.social , Julian Rose and @jrgptrs.bsky.social "
www.jcr-econ.org/public-infra...
Public Infrastructure and Economic Development: Evidence from Postal Systems A Replication Study of Rogowski et al. (American Journal of Political Science, 2022) – Journal of Comments and Replications in Economics
Peer-Reviewed. Open Access. No Author Fees.
www.jcr-econ.org

Congrats on the launch of Replication Research from JCRE! Great to see another venue promoting transparency, rigor, and replication in research.
ReplicationResearch.org is now open for submissions!

Submit replications and reproductions from many different fields, as well as conceptual contributions. With diamond OA, open and citable peer review reports, and reproducibility checks, we push the boundaries of open and fair publishing.
ReplicationResearch.org is now open for submissions!

Submit replications and reproductions from many different fields, as well as conceptual contributions. With diamond OA, open and citable peer review reports, and reproducibility checks, we push the boundaries of open and fair publishing.

Reposted by Dennis Wesselbaum

At @i4replication.bsky.social it is our ambition to foster a replication culture in the social sciences – and we hence welcome if our approaches are replicated as well: Replication Games on using LLM in experiments, in Valencia and Oxford. talkingtomachines.org/projects/ime...

Reposted by Dennis Wesselbaum

How to decide what to replicate or reproduce? We recommend priotizing studies with "high value" or unclear results, considering practical limits, watching for bias, and always communicate choices openly.

Handbook chapter: forrt.org/replication_handbook/choosing_study.html
3  Choosing the Target Study – Handbook for Reproduction and Replication Studies
How to carry out reproductions and replications in the social, cognitive, and behavioral sciences
forrt.org

Reposted by Dennis Wesselbaum

Open Science Video presented at the VfS Panel #VfS youtu.be/EWclIBQpBVs?...
Open Science in der Wirtschaftswissenschaft: Prinzipien, Nutzen und Anwendung
YouTube video by ZBW - Leibniz-Informationszentrum Wirtschaft
youtu.be
🔍Find out about the replicability crisis across fields & open research initiatives you can implement in your own work!
Attend the “Replicability Crisis” lecture by Prof. Dr. Felix Schönbrodt (@nicebread.bsky.social) on Mon 15 Sept, 9:45-10:45.
👉Register here: www.pretix.osc.lmu.de/lmu-osc/OSSS...

The results remain robust when (i) extending the
sample period from 1994-2014 to 1994-2019 and (ii) using metropolitan statistical area (MSA) level
unemployment variation instead of state-level variation.

The authors replicate Forsythe (2022), which examines how labor market transitions vary by experience over the business cycle. Using CPS data from IPUMS and new code, they confirm that hiring probability of youths is more sensitive to business-cycle conditions than for experienced individuals.

A new replication study published in JCRE. Why don’t Firms Hire Young Workers during Recessions? A Replication of Forsythe (The Economic Journal, 2022)
by Jonathan Créchet, Jing Cui, Barbara Sadaba and Antoine Sawyer, JCRE, Vol 4 (2025-4), www.jcr-econ.org/why-dont-fir...
Why don’t Firms Hire Young Workers during Recessions? A Replication of Forsythe (The Economic Journal, 2022) – Journal of Comments and Replications in Economics
www.jcr-econ.org

Reposted by Dennis Wesselbaum

Webinar alert on Data Ethics & Open Science!

Date: 1 July 2025 | 11:00–12:00 CEST

Join the WiNoDa Knowledge Lab (Museum für Naturkunde Berlin) for a timely webinar exploring: Ethical data sharing, platform independence, risks tied to AI-driven tools.

-Register: shorturl.at/7t7EB
🎉 After 2 years of work, our #OpenScience guide for researchers in developing countries is LIVE!

Check out our new preprint: osf.io/preprints/ps...

We map the opportunities 🌟 + barriers 🧱 facing Global South researchers.
*(1/4)*

Reposted by Dennis Wesselbaum

How many econ papers are computationally reproducible? 📈 The Social Science Reproduction Platform (SSRP) crowd-sources reproductions - and the team is ready to share results. New NBER working paper by Brodeur et al. shares findings from the first 487 SSRP reproductions: www.nber.org/papers/w33753
Assessing Reproducibility in Economics Using Standardized Crowd-sourced Analysis
Founded in 1920, the NBER is a private, non-profit, non-partisan organization dedicated to conducting economic research and to disseminating research findings among academics, public policy makers, an...
www.nber.org

This insight helps researchers identify which cases and configurations influence results, leading to better analytical decisions. The authors suggest that the original paper lacks conclusive evidence for its hypotheses due to insufficient variation in the empirical data sample.

The replication study can replicate its results but highlights misunderstandings in the interpretation. By correcting these issues, it questions the original study's findings and elaborates on the calculation of two fsQCA fit measures—consistency and PRI scores—in the sufficiency solution.

The findings indicate that young outsiders experience segmentation due to non-linear factors such as deindustrialization, labor market coordination, employment protection, and liberalization.

They revisit Marques and Salavisa (2017) which use fuzzy set qualitative comparative analysis to examine age-based labor market dualization in Southern European, Anglo-Saxon, and some Nordic countries.

Another paper published on JCRE: Drivers of Youth Outsiderness in European Labour Markets. A Comment on Marques and Salavisa (Socio-Economic Review, 2017) by Svenja Flechtner and Torsten Heinrich www.jcr-econ.org/drivers-of-y...
Drivers of Youth Outsiderness in European Labour Markets. A Comment on Marques and Salavisa (Socio-Economic Review, 2017) – Journal of Comments and Replications in Economics
www.jcr-econ.org

Reposted by Dennis Wesselbaum

Open Source Software and Open Science are built on the same ideas. In our upcoming Coffee Lecture on Open Science Education on 24 June, Hans-Martin von Gaudecker, University Bonn, will offer valuable insights and many practical examples. Register now: zbw.to/JVvZz
It is the week of the Replication Research Symposium! We have over 60 registrations (offline + online), about 20 contributions, and wonderful things to announce! Check out our book of abstracts or register for online participation: indico.uni-muenster.de/event/3176/

The replication study supports their findings when they use the same waves as they do, but also when they extend the sample by including more countries and interview waves and use different variables for years of education.

to analyse the impact of education on cognitive functioning decades after leaving school, and show a positive effect of education on memory scores and some evidence of a protective effect of education on the decline in verbal fluency.

The paper replicates the analysis of Schneeweis et al. (2014) using their sample as well as an extended sample. Schneeweis et al. (2014) use Survey of Health, Ageing and Retirement in Europe data and exploit compulsory schooling reforms implemented in six European countries

Another paper published on JCRE: Does Education Improve Cognitive Performance Four Decades After School Completion? A Replication Study of Nicole Schneeweis, Vegard Skirbekk and Rudolf Winter-Ebmer (Demography, 2014), by Beatrice Baaba Tawiah and Valentin Schiele www.jcr-econ.org/does-educati...
Does Education Improve Cognitive Performance Four Decades After School Completion? A Replication Study of Nicole Schneeweis, Vegard Skirbekk and Rudolf Winter-Ebmer (Demography, 2014) – Journal of Com...
www.jcr-econ.org

Reposted by Dennis Wesselbaum

This year's international Open Science Conference will be held on October 8-9 in Hamburg with a special focus on the intersection between Open Science and Artificial Intelligence (AI). We invite you to submit contributions. Deadline: 23 May. www.open-science-conference.eu/calls2025 #OSC2025

The replication study reproduces the original OLS and 2SLS findings with the same raw data; however, the author fails to replicate some of the paper's central findings using data from more recent waves collected after the publication. Plausible explanations are also discussed.

Nunn & Wantchekon (2011) detect a long-lasting impact of the slave trade on current trust levels across ethnic groups in Africa. They use data from Afrobarometer's wave 3 to construct trust measures.

A new paper published on JCRE:
The Slave Trade and the Origins of Mistrust in Africa. A Replication Study of Nunn and Wantchekon (2011), by Giulio Zanella, Journal of Comments and Replications in Economics, Vol 4 (2025-1), DOI: 10.18718/81781.40
www.jcr-econ.org/the-slave-tr...
The Slave Trade and the Origins of Mistrust in Africa. A Replication Study of Nunn and Wantchekon (2011) – Journal of Comments and Replications in Economics
www.jcr-econ.org