Studies misinformation & inauthentic behavior online.
It’s been ~10yrs since misinfo research exploded but our paradigms are stuck in the post-2016 “fake news” model
Time for new approaches:
o True/False → Content that misleads
o Belief → Behavior
o Eval interventions in ambiguous settings
It’s been ~10yrs since misinfo research exploded but our paradigms are stuck in the post-2016 “fake news” model
Time for new approaches:
o True/False → Content that misleads
o Belief → Behavior
o Eval interventions in ambiguous settings
The right often accuses fact-checkers of political bias
But we analyzed Community Notes on Musk's X and found posts flagged as "misleading" are 2.3x more likely to be written by Reps than Dems!
The issue is Reps sharing misinformation, not fact-checker bias...
www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/...
The right often accuses fact-checkers of political bias
But we analyzed Community Notes on Musk's X and found posts flagged as "misleading" are 2.3x more likely to be written by Reps than Dems!
The issue is Reps sharing misinformation, not fact-checker bias...
www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/...
Corrections of misinfo are often ignored. What can drive engagement?
Twitter field exp & survey followups find
-Social ties matter: users more likely to engage w corrections from accounts who followed user
-Shared partisanship had smaller effects on engagement
shorturl.at/0Ycdp
Corrections of misinfo are often ignored. What can drive engagement?
Twitter field exp & survey followups find
-Social ties matter: users more likely to engage w corrections from accounts who followed user
-Shared partisanship had smaller effects on engagement
shorturl.at/0Ycdp
Listen here: podcasts.ox.ac.uk/why-social-m...
Listen here: podcasts.ox.ac.uk/why-social-m...
The illusory truth effect (repetition -> belief) is core to psych of beliefs, & thought to be a deep bias impacting misinfo, persuasion & advertising
Why would cognition include such a flaw? We argue it is a rational adaptation to high-quality info environments 🧵1/
The illusory truth effect (repetition -> belief) is core to psych of beliefs, & thought to be a deep bias impacting misinfo, persuasion & advertising
Why would cognition include such a flaw? We argue it is a rational adaptation to high-quality info environments 🧵1/
Remember Musk+Zuck+Trump+Jordan etc crying fact-checker bias b/c Reps were flagged more than Dems? We analyzed Community Notes on Musk's X and guess what: posts flagged as "misleading" are 67% more likely to be written by Reps! The issue is Reps, not fact-checkers...
osf.io/preprints/ps...
Remember Musk+Zuck+Trump+Jordan etc crying fact-checker bias b/c Reps were flagged more than Dems? We analyzed Community Notes on Musk's X and guess what: posts flagged as "misleading" are 67% more likely to be written by Reps! The issue is Reps, not fact-checkers...
osf.io/preprints/ps...
What's at stake? Here are three smart takes from experts.
A short thread: 🧵
What's at stake? Here are three smart takes from experts.
A short thread: 🧵
Zuck cut moderation b/c he said people no longer want it. But he's wrong!
We polled 1k Americans and most people, including majority of Reps:
i) want content moderation
ii) don't want Community Notes w/o fact-checkers
thehill.com/opinion/tech...
Zuck cut moderation b/c he said people no longer want it. But he's wrong!
We polled 1k Americans and most people, including majority of Reps:
i) want content moderation
ii) don't want Community Notes w/o fact-checkers
thehill.com/opinion/tech...
We examine news sharing on 7 platforms:
1)Right-leaning platforms=lower quality news
2)Echo-platforms: Right-leaning news gets more engagement on right-leaning platforms, vice-versa for left-leaning
3)But low-quality news gets more engagement EVERYWHERE, even BlueSky!
osf.io/preprints/ps...
We examine news sharing on 7 platforms:
1)Right-leaning platforms=lower quality news
2)Echo-platforms: Right-leaning news gets more engagement on right-leaning platforms, vice-versa for left-leaning
3)But low-quality news gets more engagement EVERYWHERE, even BlueSky!
osf.io/preprints/ps...
Why do ppl preferentially reciprocate follows by co-partisans online? In a Twitter field exp & online survey exp we find:
-Both content *and* social prefs drive co-party tie-making
-Distinct roles for in-party pref & out-party dispref
dx.doi.org/10.1037/xge0...
Why do ppl preferentially reciprocate follows by co-partisans online? In a Twitter field exp & online survey exp we find:
-Both content *and* social prefs drive co-party tie-making
-Distinct roles for in-party pref & out-party dispref
dx.doi.org/10.1037/xge0...
Many (eg Trump JimJordan Musk Vance) have accused social media of anti-conservative bias - but is this accurate?
We test empirically, and it's more complicated than you might think: conservatives ARE suspended more, but also share more misinfo
www.nature.com/articles/s41...
Many (eg Trump JimJordan Musk Vance) have accused social media of anti-conservative bias - but is this accurate?
We test empirically, and it's more complicated than you might think: conservatives ARE suspended more, but also share more misinfo
www.nature.com/articles/s41...
www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10....
Ungated: osf.io/preprints/os...
www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10....
Ungated: osf.io/preprints/os...
rdcu.be/dT3dq
rdcu.be/dT3dq
Conspiracy beliefs famously resist correction, ya?
WRONG: We show brief convos w GPT4 reduce conspiracy beliefs by ~20%!
-Lasts over 2mo
-Works on entrenched beliefs
-Tailored AI response rebuts specific evidence offered by believers
www.science.org/doi/10.1126/...
Conspiracy beliefs famously resist correction, ya?
WRONG: We show brief convos w GPT4 reduce conspiracy beliefs by ~20%!
-Lasts over 2mo
-Works on entrenched beliefs
-Tailored AI response rebuts specific evidence offered by believers
www.science.org/doi/10.1126/...
The dangers of fact-check Whac-A-Mole: debunking false claims about the 2022 AZ election reduced misperceptions but did not improve overall election confidence
Will misinfo warning labels backfire for ppl who distrust fact-checkers? No!
Labels reduce belief in & sharing of false news even for those highly distrusting of fact-checkers - warning labels are a key tool for platforms!
rdcu.be/dSHtF
Will misinfo warning labels backfire for ppl who distrust fact-checkers? No!
Labels reduce belief in & sharing of false news even for those highly distrusting of fact-checkers - warning labels are a key tool for platforms!
rdcu.be/dSHtF
#misinformation, @cameronmartel.bsky.social said.
#misinformation, @cameronmartel.bsky.social said.
Come join me Gord Pennycook and @tomcostello.bsky.social
as we launch a research program using dialogues with LLMs as a tool to study human psychology and decision-making! Located at MIT or Cornell, and open applicants from all kinds of intellectual backgrounds/training!
Come join me Gord Pennycook and @tomcostello.bsky.social
as we launch a research program using dialogues with LLMs as a tool to study human psychology and decision-making! Located at MIT or Cornell, and open applicants from all kinds of intellectual backgrounds/training!
Twitter field exps:
-Users block counter-partisans 12x more than co-partisans
-Dems block Reps more than vice-versa
Survey exps:
-Why block? To not see blocked user's posts
-Dem/Rep diff prob bc Dems block misinfo/toxic sharers more
academic.oup.com/pnasnexus/ar...
Twitter field exps:
-Users block counter-partisans 12x more than co-partisans
-Dems block Reps more than vice-versa
Survey exps:
-Why block? To not see blocked user's posts
-Dem/Rep diff prob bc Dems block misinfo/toxic sharers more
academic.oup.com/pnasnexus/ar...
Twitter field exps:
-Users block counter-partisans 12x more than co-partisans
-Dems block Reps more than vice-versa
Survey exps:
-Why block? To not see blocked user's posts
-Dem/Rep diff prob bc Dems block misinfo/toxic sharers more
academic.oup.com/pnasnexus/ar...
In Current Opinion in Psychology, @dgrand.bsky.social & I show that the answer is YES: warnings can reduce belief & sharing by ~25-50%!
We also review moderators (eg more visible=bigger effect)
www.sciencedirect.com/science/arti...
In Current Opinion in Psychology, @dgrand.bsky.social & I show that the answer is YES: warnings can reduce belief & sharing by ~25-50%!
We also review moderators (eg more visible=bigger effect)
www.sciencedirect.com/science/arti...
Prompting accuracy can increase news sharing quality - but is this true for those on the political right?
In an ADVERSARIAL COLLABORATION we find:
➡️ Acc prompts increase sharing quality of Republicans
➡️ Some evidence of greater efficacy for those on left v right
Prompting accuracy can increase news sharing quality - but is this true for those on the political right?
In an ADVERSARIAL COLLABORATION we find:
➡️ Acc prompts increase sharing quality of Republicans
➡️ Some evidence of greater efficacy for those on left v right