Ryan Goodman
banner
rgoodlaw.bsky.social
Ryan Goodman
@rgoodlaw.bsky.social

https://www.youtube.com/@RGoodLaw

Co-editor-in-chief @justsecurity.org. Chaired Prof at NYU Law. Former Chaired Prof Harvard. Former Special Counsel Defense Dept.

https://www.justsecurity.org/author/goodmanryan

Ryan Goodman is an American legal scholar who is the Anne and Joel Ehrenkranz Professor of Law at NYU School of Law and is the founding co-editor-in-chief of its website Just Security, which focuses on U.S. national security law and policy. Goodman joined the NYU faculty in 2009. .. more

Political science 68%
Sociology 13%

Reposted by Timothy D. McBride

For context: Larry Summers continued with Epstein despite

2008: Epstein guilty plea in Florida

2008-19: MANY civil lawsuits (including by Virginia Giuffre) against Epstein for child rape/trafficking

2018: Miami Herald's @jkbjournalist.bsky.social blockbuster series on Epstein trafficking ring

2/ I was honored to team up for this article with two of the greatest international law scholars:

@mikeschmitt.bsky.social & Marko Milanovic (@unirdg-law.bsky.social)

The International Law Obligation of States to Stop Intelligence Support for U.S. Boat Strikes
www.justsecurity.org/124762/carib...
www.justsecurity.org

Reposted by Oona A. Hathaway

A counterproductive and unlawful U.S. policy:

Several States have now curtailed counter-narcotics intelligence support and/or called out U.S. boat strikes as illegal:

Canada
Colombia
EU
France
Mexico
Netherlands?
UK

We discuss their legal obligations that forbid support for boat strikes.
Obligation of States to Stop Intelligence Support for U.S. Strikes
The only way States can avoid complicity in “arbitrary killings” under IHRL is to refrain from sharing intelligence that enables them.
www.justsecurity.org

2/

"There's an awful lot of frustration with the administration abandoning what has been one of the most effective ways of going after organized crime in favor of things that sound macho but get you nowhere."

- former DOJ official who worked on maritime interdictions
Justice Department official told prosecutors that U.S. should 'just sink' drug boats
NPR interviews with current and former officials reveal more of the backstory around the military's strikes in the Caribbean.
www.npr.org

"Nine current and former U.S. officials who worked to combat transnational crime....

They questioned the legality of the deadly strikes — many referred to them as murder. ... Several of them said it may ultimately prove counterproductive."

🧵
Justice Department official told prosecutors that U.S. should 'just sink' drug boats
NPR interviews with current and former officials reveal more of the backstory around the military's strikes in the Caribbean.
www.npr.org
When former Harvard President Lawrence H. Summers was pursuing a romantic relationship with a woman he described as a mentee, he turned to a longtime associate for guidance: Jeffrey E. Epstein.

Dhruv T. Patel and Cam N. Srivastava report.
As Summers Sought Clandestine Relationship With Woman He Called a Mentee, Epstein Was His ‘Wing Man’ | News | The Harvard Crimson
When former Harvard President Lawrence H. Summers was pursuing a romantic relationship with a woman he described as a mentee, he turned to a longtime associate for guidance: convicted sex offender…
www.thecrimson.com

I spoke with @npr.org @steveinskeep.bsky.social

On most significant implications of Epstein emails

- what emails say about President Trump
- discrepancies in record
- law enforcement interest in Michael Wolff's tapes
- role of elites palling around w/ Epstein in 2019

www.npr.org/2025/11/14/n...
NYU law professor talks about the fallout from the release of Epstein documents
NPR's Steve Inskeep speaks with New York University law professor Ryan Goodman about the fallout over the latest release of documents from the Epstein estate.
www.npr.org

"Trump and his administration on Wednesday ramped up a pressure campaign on congressional Republicans who are pushing for a full release of the [DOJ] files about the convicted sex offender Jeffrey Epstein...

Top officials met in the White House Situation Room on Wednesday with" Rep. Boebert.
Trump Ramps Up Pressure on G.O.P. To Thwart Epstein Vote
www.nytimes.com

3/ Gift article to NYT:

Epstein Alleged in Emails That Trump Knew of His Conduct
In a message obtained by Congress, the convicted sex offender Jeffrey Epstein wrote that Donald J. Trump spent hours at his house with one of Mr. Epstein’s victims.

www.nytimes.com/2025/11/12/u...
Epstein Alleged in Emails That Trump Knew of His Conduct
www.nytimes.com

2/ Second email is evidence of President Trump's knowledge of Epstein's AND Maxwell's activities, but also has an element in Trump's favor.

Epstein to Michael Wolff, January 31, 2019

“Of course he knew about the girls as he asked Ghislaine to stop.”
It begins. Clearly incriminating evidence against president of the United States.

Epstein to Maxwell, April 2, 2011:

"i want you to realize that that dog that hasn't barked is trump. [VICTIM] spent hours at my house with him ,, he has never once been mentioned. police chief. etc."

2/ Gift link to Judge Wolf's essay, "Why I Am Resigning"

www.theatlantic.com/ideas/2025/1...
Why I Am Resigning
A federal judge explains his reasoning for leaving the bench.
www.theatlantic.com

Republican-Appointed Judge Resigns to Raise Alarm About President Trump and Rule of Law

Judge Mark Wolf resigned on Friday, published an essay over the weekend, and here speaks to Erica Hill @outfrontcnn.bsky.social

www.instagram.com/reel/DQ7EbaL...
Login • Instagram
Welcome back to Instagram. Sign in to check out what your friends, family & interests have been capturing & sharing around the world.
www.instagram.com

3/ "Canada ... which has helped the US Coast Guard interdict suspected drug traffickers in the Caribbean for nearly two decades, has also distanced itself from the US military strikes. ... made clear to the US that it does not want its intelligence being used to help target boats for deadly strikes"

2/ That is more specific than earlier reporting on tying Admiral Holsey's resignation directly to his concerns about the legality of boat strikes.

Earlier reporting:

www.cnn.com/2025/10/16/p...
Commander overseeing US forces in the Caribbean to retire one year into tenure | CNN Politics
The admiral overseeing US Southern Command, which has responsibility for forces in the Caribbean, where the US has carried out multiple legally ambiguous strikes against alleged drug cartels, is retir...
www.cnn.com

"The commander of US Southern Command, Adm. Alvin Holsey, offered to resign during a tense meeting last month with Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth ... after he raised questions about the legality of the strikes ... Holsey will leave his post in December, just one year into his tenure."
Exclusive: UK suspends some intelligence sharing with US over boat strike concerns in major break | CNN Politics
The United Kingdom is no longer sharing intelligence with the US about suspected drug trafficking vessels in the Caribbean because it does not want to be complicit in US military strikes and believes ...
edition.cnn.com

Reposted by Brendan Nyhan

2/ A counterproductive U.S. policy

"For years, the UK, which controls a number of territories in the Caribbean where it bases intelligence assets, has helped the US locate vessels suspected of carrying drugs so that the US Coast Guard could interdict them."

Scoop by @natashabertrand.bsky.social
Exclusive: UK suspends some intelligence sharing with US over boat strike concerns in major break | CNN Politics
The United Kingdom is no longer sharing intelligence with the US about suspected drug trafficking vessels in the Caribbean because it does not want to be complicit in US military strikes and believes ...
edition.cnn.com
One of many costs to US murder (sorry, no better word for it) in Caribbean:

"United Kingdom is no longer sharing intelligence with the US about suspected drug trafficking vessels in the Caribbean because it does not want to be complicit in US military strikes and believes the attacks are illegal."
Exclusive: UK suspends some intelligence sharing with US over boat strike concerns in major break | CNN Politics
The United Kingdom is no longer sharing intelligence with the US about suspected drug trafficking vessels in the Caribbean because it does not want to be complicit in US military strikes and believes ...
edition.cnn.com

Something smells very fishy in this DOJ action:

What do actions of Brennan, Strzok and Page who left office several years before MAL search have to do with the southern district of Florida?

Likely takes a bogus omnibus-conspiracy theory to get there, as this report indicates.
Feds move to subpoena former CIA director and others who investigated Russian interference in Trump’s 2016 campaign | CNN Politics
Prosecutors in Florida moved to issue subpoenas to former CIA Director John Brennan and other former officials as the Justice Department investigates the federal government’s counterintelligence inves...
www.cnn.com

7/ The Trump DOJ's argument on the War Powers law was reported over the weekend by:

WaPo: @ellenwapo.bsky.social and Noah Robertson
www.washingtonpost.com/national-sec...

NYT: @charliesavage.bsky.social and @julianbarnes.bsky.social
www.nytimes.com/2025/11/01/u...
War Powers Law Does Not Apply to Trump’s Boat Strikes, Administration Says
www.nytimes.com

6/ As NYT points out, even Obama's head of Department of Justice's Office of Legal Counsel and his DoD General Counsel rejected the theory.

NYT report from 2011:
www.nytimes.com/2011/06/18/w...

Great book on 2011 episode: @charliesavage.bsky.social's Power Wars
charliesavage.com/books/power-...
2 Top Lawyers Lost to Obama in Libya War Policy Debate (Published 2011)
www.nytimes.com

5/ The Just Security article at the top of this thread is by the great expert on this topic, @bcfinucane.bsky.social, who handled war powers reporting for the State Department under Obama and Trump 1.0.

www.justsecurity.org/123844/war-p...
Dissecting the Trump Administration’s Effort to Circumvent the War Powers Resolution for Boat Strikes
Analysis of Trump administration's claim that War Powers Resolution's regulating US troops in "hostilities" does not apply to boat strikes.
www.justsecurity.org

4/ Standing by principle, Senator Rand Paul is now working to pass bipartisan war powers legislation on the boat strikes that is consistent with the Constitution and that seeks to preserve Congress' core interests in war-making.

time.com/7329015/trum...
time.com

3/ In 2011, those in Congress who flat rejected the Obama (now Obama-Trump) theory of "hostilities" on the War Powers Resolution included:

Rand Paul
Mike Lee
Ron Johnson
John Cornyn
Bill Cassidy
Shelley Capito
Tim Scott

Kristi Noem

2/ In 2011 Libya operation, Obama tried the same theory as part of a four-factor test. Trump does not even have three of those four factors.

On the fourth one, which Obama tried (and now Trump does) there was very strong bipartisan pushback including from ...

Kristi Noem...

Reposted by David R. Miller

Today, Trump-Hegseth run out of time on War Powers Resolution and boat strikes.

DOJ has come up with a theory why the law does not apply.

It's wrong, and per this article, several GOP Senators and a Trump cabinet member flat rejected that theory when Obama tried it in 2011.

🧵 1/
Dissecting the Trump Administration’s Effort to Circumvent the War Powers Resolution for Boat Strikes
Analysis of Trump administration's claim that War Powers Resolution's regulating US troops in "hostilities" does not apply to boat strikes.
www.justsecurity.org

District court in Oregon v Trump moves to preliminary injunction following trial. Blocks Hegseth's deploying members of the National Guard in Oregon.

Will issue final order by Friday, Nov. 7.

storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.us...
#134 in State of Oregon v. Trump (D. Or., 3:25-cv-01756) – CourtListener.com
OPINION AND ORDER: Pending this Court's issuance of a final opinion and order resolving Plaintiffs' request for a permanent injunction by November 7, 2025, at 5 p.m. PT, Defendant Secretary Hegseth is...
storage.courtlistener.com

2/ As we discuss, also keep a lookout for new bipartisan legislation:

Rand Paul: Senate Will Get Another Chance to Limit Trump’s Venezuela Strikes
Senate to Get 2nd Chance to Limit Trump’s Venezuela Strikes
Rand Paul tells TIME he is working with Democrats to force a vote on a resolution to block Trump's Venezuela strikes as early as next week
time.com

On Monday, U.S. military strikes on boats become congressionally prohibited under War Powers Resolution.

A clip of my conversation with @billkristolbulwark.bsky.social @thebulwark.com below.⤵️ Explaining why Monday is a new frontier.

Full video: www.youtube.com/live/lUeaFCu...

youtu.be/VY4qvIVnYpA
Monday: Boat Strikes Become Congressionally Prohibited
YouTube video by Ryan Goodman
youtu.be