For example the real tide (as of 18:20) is rising to HIGH so that could be the set rule for your current game.
www.tidetimes.org.uk/tobermory-ti...

Then the 'Whirlpool' at Sea. Cards played face down then shuffled and dealt. A bit of randomness but a neat decision as to what card to add to the mix. If the Lighthouse is out the Lead player doesn't have to shuffle. Strong as they either likely win OR shuffle in rubbish and hope to shed that card.

Including making it more meaningful to win (perhaps more narrative too). Suggestion was to have a picture frame to give to the winner. I've mocked up what a framed board might look like and it'd be class to have a wipe clean badge that the winner "signs" and the finished piece becomes their artwork.

Also, I've made a first pass at a rulebook so if anyone's interested in more detail on the game here it is. Feedback is very welcome. Note this is just a draft really and mainly posted early for those curious about the progress. Cheers! Rob.
drive.google.com/file/d/1pCl9...

Anyway, I was absolutely buzzing and got some incredible feedback.

Hearing the 'oooh' as the art side of the first card was revealed was just amazing.

It's now registered to public playtest later this month at Ancient Robot Games in Edinburgh. More on that soon hopefully.