Sandbag
banner
sandbag-eu.bsky.social
Sandbag
@sandbag-eu.bsky.social
We conduct data-driven and evidence-based advocacy to improve EU climate policy.
✅ The coalition calls for:

• A halt to ICC expansion until reformed
• Updated CO₂ factors based on real marginal emissions in each bidding zone

📩 ETS revenues must fund real decarbonisation, not fossil subsidies.
👇 Read the letter:
sandbag.be/2025/11/13/i...

4/4
ICC reform and expansion risks diverting ETS revenues from real climate action | Sandbag
Sandbag joins 14 NGOs in calling on the European Commission to reform the Indirect Cost Compensation (ICC) scheme before expanding it.
sandbag.be
November 13, 2025 at 12:57 PM
⚠️ What’s wrong with the proposal?

• Subsidies to sectors with low carbon leakage risk
• Compensation based on fossil fuel averages, not real-time grid mix
• ❌ No obligation to invest in clean tech or cut fossil energy use

3/4
November 13, 2025 at 12:55 PM
💶 In 2023, nearly €4bn in ETS revenues were spent on ICC — 16.4%+ of the total.

Now, the Commission plans to double the number of eligible sectors and keep using outdated fossil CO₂ factors — risking further diversion of funds away from climate action.

2/4
November 13, 2025 at 12:54 PM
👇 Read it here:
sandbag.be/2025/11/12/s...

👇Read it on European Commission portal: ec.europa.eu/info/law/bet...

#RecycledContent #Decarbonisation #CleanSteel

4/4
Sandbag’s feedback to the call for evidence on the Circular Economy Act | Sandbag
sandbag.be
November 12, 2025 at 12:14 PM
• Scrap classification and certification
• Minimum recycled content requirements for all steel on the EU market, including imports

❗The Act can address systemic fragmentation and support low-carbon steel production by aligning policy incentives with circular material use.

3/4
November 12, 2025 at 12:09 PM
Sandbag’s submission focuses on the carbon-intensive flat steel sector, where scrap remains underused despite its decarbonisation potential.

📌 Recommendations include:

• Design-for-recyclability obligations
• Avoid downcycling/export of high-grade scrap
• Improve traceability tools

2/4
November 12, 2025 at 12:07 PM
✅ To deliver real climate benefits, electrification must be strategic and flexible — with new renewables added on top of what’s already needed to decarbonise power grids.

❌ Otherwise, the EU risks locking in fossil-fuel output for years

👇Read our report
sandbag.be/2025/06/12/g...

3/3
Getting Electrification Right: The broader challenge of induced emissions | Sandbag
sandbag.be
October 31, 2025 at 1:17 PM
Sandbag’s Getting Electrification Right warns:

If electricity demand rises faster than renewable supply, fossil generation fills the gap.

❗Industrial electrification without flexibility risks induced emissions — more fossil, not less.

2/3
October 31, 2025 at 1:15 PM
✅ CBAM can work for Africa — it supports a shift to cleaner production

🏭 Lower emissions = fewer costs
📦 Competitive exports
💡 Long-term industrial advantage

👇 Read Sandbag’s chapter (pp. 59–60):

sandbag.be/wp-content/u...

#CBAM #CarbonMarkets #Africa

3/3
sandbag.be
October 30, 2025 at 3:43 PM
📊 Net CBAM costs for Africa could fall to €670M — even without cleaner production — thanks to higher EU selling prices. 🌍

A 50% carbon price of the EU price in Africa could flip this into a €134M net gain.

📈 Aluminium = gain
⚠️ Steel & fertilisers = net costs

2/3
October 30, 2025 at 3:28 PM
4/4

This would:

✔️ Incentivise clean electricity
✔️ Prevent windfall profits
✔️ Cut costs for Member States
✔️ Align with a CBAM extension to indirect emissions

📄 Read our full response:

🔗 sandbag.be/2025/08/21/s...

#CBAM #CarbonMarkets
State Aid for Indirect Carbon Costs: Reform before extending! | Sandbag
sandbag.be
October 22, 2025 at 9:14 AM
3/4

Sandbag recommends clear reforms:

✅ Only compensate the non-fossil share of electricity consumed
✅ Limit support to periods when fossil fuels set the marginal price

This aligns incentives and avoids wasteful spending.

#StateAid #NetZero
October 22, 2025 at 9:11 AM
2/4

ICC was meant to protect industry from carbon leakage. But in its current form, it:

• Compensates all electricity use, incl. fossil
• Discourages clean power
• Grows with electrification
• Clashes with plans to extend CBAM to indirect emissions
October 22, 2025 at 9:10 AM
❗The simulator is designed to support evidence-based decisions on decarbonisation and climate policy.

#CBAM #CarbonPricing #ClimatePolicy

4/4
October 16, 2025 at 12:47 PM
🔍 Built with transparent, user-controlled assumptions, the simulator lets users model scenarios & policy choices, and assess:

• 💰 Net CBAM cost = fees paid – revenue gains from EU sales
• ⛔ Effects as free allocation phases out in Europe’s carbon market

3/4
October 16, 2025 at 12:46 PM
The tool enables users to:

• 📈 Estimate CBAM-related costs by country, sector & product
• 🧾 Explore policy responses incl. domestic carbon pricing and resource reallocation
• 🔄 Simulate scope extensions: indirect emissions, new sectors, upstream/downstream products

2/4
October 16, 2025 at 12:45 PM
Beyond costs, CBAM is also an opportunity.

Cleaner production could make African industries more competitive in a decarbonising global market.

📅 Simulations launch 16 Oct with Sandbag’s CBAM Simulator

👉 Blog: sandbag.be/2025/10/14/c...

#CBAM #Africa #ClimatePolicy

4/4
The EU CBAM: a two-way street between the EU and Africa
How the EU's CBAM affects African exporters: new Sandbag paper finds both financial risks and opportunities for more sustainable trade.
sandbag.be
October 15, 2025 at 8:02 PM