Occasional sailor. Historian. JRR Tolkien fan.
Ex-HCSC. Ex-Chicago Tribune (used to sometimes pop up on WGN and CLTV).
The HMS Chesapeake of your post only took its name.
The HMS Chesapeake of your post only took its name.
en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/USS_Che...
en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/USS_Che...
I stand corrected—the Narsilion was not the Trees’ story, but the Sun & Moon (red & white lights). Their rising heralded the Noldor’s return, which adds to your Maedhros idea.
As @janeellen.bsky.social says, in the chaos, tales were easily lost.
I stand corrected—the Narsilion was not the Trees’ story, but the Sun & Moon (red & white lights). Their rising heralded the Noldor’s return, which adds to your Maedhros idea.
As @janeellen.bsky.social says, in the chaos, tales were easily lost.
I love the idea of Maedhros’s sword going to the true heirs of Elros. (Had primogeniture existed from the start in Númenor—vs. male primogeniture—the Lords of Andúnië would have been the kings. Silmariën was Tar-Meneldur’s elder sister.)
I love the idea of Maedhros’s sword going to the true heirs of Elros. (Had primogeniture existed from the start in Númenor—vs. male primogeniture—the Lords of Andúnië would have been the kings. Silmariën was Tar-Meneldur’s elder sister.)
My concern: Though Maedhros’s original sword was lost to his captors, would he use one forged by the dwarf smith Telchar in Nogrod (maker of Angrist and Hador’s helm) and not a Fëanor-forged blade?
My concern: Though Maedhros’s original sword was lost to his captors, would he use one forged by the dwarf smith Telchar in Nogrod (maker of Angrist and Hador’s helm) and not a Fëanor-forged blade?
I know this because one of the islands where we built a fort—Ft. Frank—to defend Manila Bay was named Carabao. It was on the Pico de Loro/Cavite side of the channel, farthest from Corregidor/Ft. Mills.
Reindeer, you say? 🤔
I know this because one of the islands where we built a fort—Ft. Frank—to defend Manila Bay was named Carabao. It was on the Pico de Loro/Cavite side of the channel, farthest from Corregidor/Ft. Mills.
Reindeer, you say? 🤔