macfergusson
@macfergusson.bsky.social
I like SQL Server and Star Wars Unlimited.
My terrible blog here:
https://www.macfergusson.com
SWU collection:
https://nexus.cascadegames.com/resources/Rules_Clarifications/
My terrible blog here:
https://www.macfergusson.com
SWU collection:
https://nexus.cascadegames.com/resources/Rules_Clarifications/
@davflamerock.bsky.social AP plays On Top of Things on a friendly unit. NAP plays Confiscate to defeat the upgrade. Does the lasting effect of "Attached unit can't be attacked this phase" still protect the unit?
April 30, 2025 at 12:23 AM
@davflamerock.bsky.social AP plays On Top of Things on a friendly unit. NAP plays Confiscate to defeat the upgrade. Does the lasting effect of "Attached unit can't be attacked this phase" still protect the unit?
@davflamerock.bsky.social If JTL Lando uses leader ability to play Brain Invaders, is the shield token still able to be placed? Since the costs were paid, we're thinking the entire ability still needs to finish resolving, despite leaders losing their abilities when the unit enters play.
April 29, 2025 at 10:42 PM
@davflamerock.bsky.social If JTL Lando uses leader ability to play Brain Invaders, is the shield token still able to be placed? Since the costs were paid, we're thinking the entire ability still needs to finish resolving, despite leaders losing their abilities when the unit enters play.
@davflamerock.bsky.social Is the leader action ability on SOR Palpatine intended to be templated as sequential or simultaneous?
April 17, 2025 at 4:34 PM
@davflamerock.bsky.social Is the leader action ability on SOR Palpatine intended to be templated as sequential or simultaneous?
@davflamerock.bsky.social If AP's JTL L3-37 would be defeated but is instead attached as a pilot, does NAP get the discount on Bravado, because of replacement rules, or no discount, because of Determining Responsibility rules?
April 16, 2025 at 5:15 PM
@davflamerock.bsky.social If AP's JTL L3-37 would be defeated but is instead attached as a pilot, does NAP get the discount on Bravado, because of replacement rules, or no discount, because of Determining Responsibility rules?
@davflamerock.bsky.social Double checking intent vs actual language on SOR Falcon: Does ability trigger if the controller doesn't ready any cards in regroup? (This seems highly unlikely to actually come up in a real game, but...)
April 3, 2025 at 10:37 PM
@davflamerock.bsky.social Double checking intent vs actual language on SOR Falcon: Does ability trigger if the controller doesn't ready any cards in regroup? (This seems highly unlikely to actually come up in a real game, but...)
@davflamerock.bsky.social If Player 1 pilots Vonreg on Avenger, and Player 2 plays Brain Invaders, does Avenger lose On Attack ability or no?
March 27, 2025 at 4:27 PM
@davflamerock.bsky.social If Player 1 pilots Vonreg on Avenger, and Player 2 plays Brain Invaders, does Avenger lose On Attack ability or no?
@davflamerock.bsky.social P1 passes. P2 uses Kazuda leader action then Claims initiative. Consecutive turns so Action phase is over.
P1 passes. P2 uses Kazuda leader action then also passes. Phase ends?
Is this considered to be 'consecutive'? Does consecutive apply to 'turn' or to 'action'?
P1 passes. P2 uses Kazuda leader action then also passes. Phase ends?
Is this considered to be 'consecutive'? Does consecutive apply to 'turn' or to 'action'?
March 17, 2025 at 4:22 PM
@davflamerock.bsky.social P1 passes. P2 uses Kazuda leader action then Claims initiative. Consecutive turns so Action phase is over.
P1 passes. P2 uses Kazuda leader action then also passes. Phase ends?
Is this considered to be 'consecutive'? Does consecutive apply to 'turn' or to 'action'?
P1 passes. P2 uses Kazuda leader action then also passes. Phase ends?
Is this considered to be 'consecutive'? Does consecutive apply to 'turn' or to 'action'?
@davflamerock.bsky.social If I play Triple Dark Raid and attach Chewbacca via piloting on to that ship, then my opponent plays Traitorous and takes control of that ship with chewy attached, will that ship return to my hand at regroup?
March 14, 2025 at 7:22 PM
@davflamerock.bsky.social If I play Triple Dark Raid and attach Chewbacca via piloting on to that ship, then my opponent plays Traitorous and takes control of that ship with chewy attached, will that ship return to my hand at regroup?
@davflamerock.bsky.social if I use Annihilator's when played on a Clone copying, say, Chewbacca, do I discard Clones or Chewbaccas from the deck and hand? Pretty sure it's Chewbacca, right?
March 12, 2025 at 6:30 PM
@davflamerock.bsky.social if I use Annihilator's when played on a Clone copying, say, Chewbacca, do I discard Clones or Chewbaccas from the deck and hand? Pretty sure it's Chewbacca, right?
@davflamerock.bsky.social people keep arguing over Focus Fire. Is it one instance of damage or multiple instances of damage?
March 11, 2025 at 6:53 AM
@davflamerock.bsky.social people keep arguing over Focus Fire. Is it one instance of damage or multiple instances of damage?
@davflamerock.bsky.social what happens to a captured unit guarded by a pilot unit that gets picked up by Corvus?
March 10, 2025 at 2:15 AM
@davflamerock.bsky.social what happens to a captured unit guarded by a pilot unit that gets picked up by Corvus?
@davflamerock.bsky.social Droid Missile Platform attached to Targeting Computer is defeated. Does the ability to assign indirect damage still apply due to Last Known Info or not because upgrade is no longer attached and is in discard after unit is defeated?
March 9, 2025 at 9:45 PM
@davflamerock.bsky.social Droid Missile Platform attached to Targeting Computer is defeated. Does the ability to assign indirect damage still apply due to Last Known Info or not because upgrade is no longer attached and is in discard after unit is defeated?
@davflamerock.bsky.social AP has 2 space units in play and NAP has a ground unit in play. When AP plays Reckless Torrent, is When Played able to damage NAP ground unit based on do as much as you can, or does it require a friendly and enemy unit to index what "same arena" means and nothing happens?
March 8, 2025 at 10:00 PM
@davflamerock.bsky.social AP has 2 space units in play and NAP has a ground unit in play. When AP plays Reckless Torrent, is When Played able to damage NAP ground unit based on do as much as you can, or does it require a friendly and enemy unit to index what "same arena" means and nothing happens?
@davflamerock.bsky.social Comparing Admiral Yularen -
Fleet Coordinator with Regional Governor, if they change control RG doesn't change which OPPOENT is impacted, but Yularen references FRIENDLY UNITS, so his lasting effect does now change who it applies to, right?
Fleet Coordinator with Regional Governor, if they change control RG doesn't change which OPPOENT is impacted, but Yularen references FRIENDLY UNITS, so his lasting effect does now change who it applies to, right?
March 5, 2025 at 7:15 PM
@davflamerock.bsky.social Comparing Admiral Yularen -
Fleet Coordinator with Regional Governor, if they change control RG doesn't change which OPPOENT is impacted, but Yularen references FRIENDLY UNITS, so his lasting effect does now change who it applies to, right?
Fleet Coordinator with Regional Governor, if they change control RG doesn't change which OPPOENT is impacted, but Yularen references FRIENDLY UNITS, so his lasting effect does now change who it applies to, right?
@davflamerock.bsky.social so it looks like "Survivors' Gauntlet" can move "Luke Skywalker - You Still With Me?" from a vehicle on to a non-vehicle unit, since there's no inherent eligibility criteria attached to the Pilot trait? Only the Piloting play a card action specifies "vehicle" unit.
March 4, 2025 at 4:23 AM
@davflamerock.bsky.social so it looks like "Survivors' Gauntlet" can move "Luke Skywalker - You Still With Me?" from a vehicle on to a non-vehicle unit, since there's no inherent eligibility criteria attached to the Pilot trait? Only the Piloting play a card action specifies "vehicle" unit.
@davflamerock.bsky.social Play JTL Poe Command unit with Sneak Attack, his when played ability makes him a pilot upgrade. He is no longer a unit, so Sneak Attack fails to find the unit played at start of regroup phase?
February 26, 2025 at 4:35 PM
@davflamerock.bsky.social Play JTL Poe Command unit with Sneak Attack, his when played ability makes him a pilot upgrade. He is no longer a unit, so Sneak Attack fails to find the unit played at start of regroup phase?
@davflamerock.bsky.social Can I "fail to find" cards in my opponent's deck when I use Annihilator's When Played ability if I want to leave some cards of the same name behind? We've not seen a "search your opponent's deck" before.
February 21, 2025 at 8:03 PM
@davflamerock.bsky.social Can I "fail to find" cards in my opponent's deck when I use Annihilator's When Played ability if I want to leave some cards of the same name behind? We've not seen a "search your opponent's deck" before.
@davflamerock.bsky.social CR4 change for "lose" from stream, since Kaz says "lose all abilities for round" that means the unit can't gain ANY abilities for that round. A card that says Lose a specific ability, like Specforce vs Sentinel, means they could not regain Sentinel for that phase. Right?
February 19, 2025 at 9:33 PM
@davflamerock.bsky.social CR4 change for "lose" from stream, since Kaz says "lose all abilities for round" that means the unit can't gain ANY abilities for that round. A card that says Lose a specific ability, like Specforce vs Sentinel, means they could not regain Sentinel for that phase. Right?
@davflamerock.bsky.social If Active Player plays Change of Heart on a MagnaGuard Wing Leader that had already used its action ability, can the new controller use the ability, or is the once per round effect tied to the copy of the card regardless of the change in controller?
February 18, 2025 at 5:13 AM
@davflamerock.bsky.social If Active Player plays Change of Heart on a MagnaGuard Wing Leader that had already used its action ability, can the new controller use the ability, or is the once per round effect tied to the copy of the card regardless of the change in controller?
@davflamerock.bsky.social Does JTL Trench leader deploy deal empty deck damage because it doesn't say "may draw" or are there zero remaining cards to draw from, so you aren't drawing a card?
February 13, 2025 at 7:26 PM
@davflamerock.bsky.social Does JTL Trench leader deploy deal empty deck damage because it doesn't say "may draw" or are there zero remaining cards to draw from, so you aren't drawing a card?
@davflamerock.bsky.social 6.2.3.A Determine Costs timing, can JTL Krennic be exploited and still grant his discount as well?
February 13, 2025 at 7:00 PM
@davflamerock.bsky.social 6.2.3.A Determine Costs timing, can JTL Krennic be exploited and still grant his discount as well?
@davflamerock.bsky.social We know that pilot leaders deployed as upgrades can be defeated by bamboozle. Does pilot Luke defeat protection prevent that, or does it count as "moved to hand" and then the leader rules kick in to defeat Luke since that is an invalid zone for that card?
February 13, 2025 at 5:22 PM
@davflamerock.bsky.social We know that pilot leaders deployed as upgrades can be defeated by bamboozle. Does pilot Luke defeat protection prevent that, or does it count as "moved to hand" and then the leader rules kick in to defeat Luke since that is an invalid zone for that card?
@davflamerock.bsky.social If Phantom II is attached to The Ghost, can Survivors Gauntlet move it, or is The Ghost the only “eligible” unit for it to attach to, or does it not actually count as an upgrade for that purpose at all? The wording there is a little strange.
February 13, 2025 at 12:21 AM
@davflamerock.bsky.social If Phantom II is attached to The Ghost, can Survivors Gauntlet move it, or is The Ghost the only “eligible” unit for it to attach to, or does it not actually count as an upgrade for that purpose at all? The wording there is a little strange.
@davflamerock.bsky.social Hey if I "No Glory, Only Results" a Snoke, does my opponent lose all their 2 HP units currently in play? Based on the 1.16.5 game state rules it seems like we pause the event resolution due to E, defeat units, and then move on to defeat Snoke due to the rest of the text.
February 12, 2025 at 8:18 PM
@davflamerock.bsky.social Hey if I "No Glory, Only Results" a Snoke, does my opponent lose all their 2 HP units currently in play? Based on the 1.16.5 game state rules it seems like we pause the event resolution due to E, defeat units, and then move on to defeat Snoke due to the rest of the text.
@davflamerock.bsky.social If Caught In The Crossfire is played in Twin Suns by Player A and they select a unit from Player B and a unit from Player C in the same arena, and Player C's unit has a bounty and is defeated, does Player A or Player B get to collect the bounty?
December 6, 2024 at 6:58 PM
@davflamerock.bsky.social If Caught In The Crossfire is played in Twin Suns by Player A and they select a unit from Player B and a unit from Player C in the same arena, and Player C's unit has a bounty and is defeated, does Player A or Player B get to collect the bounty?