Liz Dolfi
@lizbee.bsky.social
big dork. recovering academic. my hard skills include drinking too much coffee and monologuing about evangelical moral panics and the sex lives of puritans
Even so, I think it matters that the best available solution to ChatGPT cheating is, truly, better teaching.
May 7, 2025 at 6:07 PM
Even so, I think it matters that the best available solution to ChatGPT cheating is, truly, better teaching.
I also understand that prioritizing thoughtful instructional methods and assessment is time-intensive in a way that is deeply at odds with the realities of the neoliberal university.
May 7, 2025 at 6:07 PM
I also understand that prioritizing thoughtful instructional methods and assessment is time-intensive in a way that is deeply at odds with the realities of the neoliberal university.
I understand why these kinds of solutions can feel unsatisfying or inadequate to the moment, but to me it feels important not to lose sight of the fact that the courses that are most susceptible to this kind of cheating are large lecture courses, which we already know are pedagogically ineffective.
May 7, 2025 at 6:07 PM
I understand why these kinds of solutions can feel unsatisfying or inadequate to the moment, but to me it feels important not to lose sight of the fact that the courses that are most susceptible to this kind of cheating are large lecture courses, which we already know are pedagogically ineffective.
Imo they are easily the best way to gain an understanding of what your students have actually learned in terms of content and analytical skills.
May 7, 2025 at 6:07 PM
Imo they are easily the best way to gain an understanding of what your students have actually learned in terms of content and analytical skills.
Oral exams are very time-intensive for instructors (not coincidentally, the faculty members I know who use them are deeply serious and dedicated teachers) but they are so rewarding.
May 7, 2025 at 6:07 PM
Oral exams are very time-intensive for instructors (not coincidentally, the faculty members I know who use them are deeply serious and dedicated teachers) but they are so rewarding.
Open-book, written, timed exams can be a fantastic way to assess understanding. I found this especially useful when I was teaching Contemporary Civilization, a required great books course that is very Chat GPT friendly in content.
May 7, 2025 at 6:07 PM
Open-book, written, timed exams can be a fantastic way to assess understanding. I found this especially useful when I was teaching Contemporary Civilization, a required great books course that is very Chat GPT friendly in content.
4. The NY mag article glosses over bringing back oral exams and blue book exams, but I think these are both incredible tools that we should take more seriously.
May 7, 2025 at 6:07 PM
4. The NY mag article glosses over bringing back oral exams and blue book exams, but I think these are both incredible tools that we should take more seriously.
While students could still use ChatGPT for assignments like this, they would at least be forced to use it more thoughtfully (revising, editing, adapting, etc). It doesn’t prevent cheating, but it ensures that some thinking, analysis, and writing is still happening regardless.
May 7, 2025 at 6:07 PM
While students could still use ChatGPT for assignments like this, they would at least be forced to use it more thoughtfully (revising, editing, adapting, etc). It doesn’t prevent cheating, but it ensures that some thinking, analysis, and writing is still happening regardless.
This sounds like a lot more work for teachers, and it is, but students ended up writing really incredible papers because they had to work on their prose and their ideas. It was also helpful for students who struggled with executive function and procrastination.
May 7, 2025 at 6:07 PM
This sounds like a lot more work for teachers, and it is, but students ended up writing really incredible papers because they had to work on their prose and their ideas. It was also helpful for students who struggled with executive function and procrastination.
Students couldn’t get from A to B without making a lot of choices about their argument and the structure of their paper that they had to discuss with me in class or in office hours.
May 7, 2025 at 6:07 PM
Students couldn’t get from A to B without making a lot of choices about their argument and the structure of their paper that they had to discuss with me in class or in office hours.
Students in my classes would have to produce a topic proposal, an annotated bibliography, an outline, a proposed introduction, a first draft, and a final draft, all of which were graded and received detailed comments.
May 7, 2025 at 6:07 PM
Students in my classes would have to produce a topic proposal, an annotated bibliography, an outline, a proposed introduction, a first draft, and a final draft, all of which were graded and received detailed comments.
3. I used a lot of scaffolding for longer writing assignments. Even before the AI crisis, I never assigned a research paper in my seminars with a single deadline.
May 7, 2025 at 6:07 PM
3. I used a lot of scaffolding for longer writing assignments. Even before the AI crisis, I never assigned a research paper in my seminars with a single deadline.
It’s also a chance for them to feel clever and empowered as readers while thinking about the conditions of their own education – for a lot of students that will help tip the scales.
May 7, 2025 at 6:07 PM
It’s also a chance for them to feel clever and empowered as readers while thinking about the conditions of their own education – for a lot of students that will help tip the scales.
Could students cheat and use a chatbot to write their response as well? Sure. But the assignment is a light lift and they know there will be a class discussion about what they observed and how they used the tool.
May 7, 2025 at 6:07 PM
Could students cheat and use a chatbot to write their response as well? Sure. But the assignment is a light lift and they know there will be a class discussion about what they observed and how they used the tool.
2. I used Chat GPT in early, low-stakes assignments. For instance: a.) use ChatGPT to produce a reading response to an article on the Second Great Awakening and b.) write a few sentences assessing whether the bot came up with a “good” response, if you agree, and how you might improve it.
May 7, 2025 at 6:07 PM
2. I used Chat GPT in early, low-stakes assignments. For instance: a.) use ChatGPT to produce a reading response to an article on the Second Great Awakening and b.) write a few sentences assessing whether the bot came up with a “good” response, if you agree, and how you might improve it.
1. I assumed that all students were using ChatGPT despite stated class policies and I assumed that I would not be able to tell when they were using it. Imo, anyone who says they can tell the difference between bad/weird undergraduate writing and bad/weird chatGPT writing is lying.
May 7, 2025 at 6:07 PM
1. I assumed that all students were using ChatGPT despite stated class policies and I assumed that I would not be able to tell when they were using it. Imo, anyone who says they can tell the difference between bad/weird undergraduate writing and bad/weird chatGPT writing is lying.
I feel the Chat GPT doom (the kids are not alright), but I also believe that well-designed assessments can make cheating more difficult and less appealing. Here are some ways that I tried to address AI cheating in my final courses as a college instructor.
May 7, 2025 at 6:07 PM
I feel the Chat GPT doom (the kids are not alright), but I also believe that well-designed assessments can make cheating more difficult and less appealing. Here are some ways that I tried to address AI cheating in my final courses as a college instructor.
I think this is a big part of the reason that so many assignments feel pointless to students and why Chat GPT feel like such a crisis even within the controlled environment of a college course. Many professors are not thinking about what they are assessing and WHY when they assign a paper.
May 7, 2025 at 6:07 PM
I think this is a big part of the reason that so many assignments feel pointless to students and why Chat GPT feel like such a crisis even within the controlled environment of a college course. Many professors are not thinking about what they are assessing and WHY when they assign a paper.
Generally, great teachers get there through effort, intuition, observation, and luck – they see what works well in other classrooms, and experiment over time. They are great because they are smart and motivated to teach effectively, not because they are trained in pedagogy as a skill and science.
May 7, 2025 at 6:07 PM
Generally, great teachers get there through effort, intuition, observation, and luck – they see what works well in other classrooms, and experiment over time. They are great because they are smart and motivated to teach effectively, not because they are trained in pedagogy as a skill and science.
First, the obvious: faculty at colleges and universities are appointed based on their research, not the quality of their teaching. Most doctoral students receive little to no training in teaching, and the training they receive certainly isn’t evidence-based or situated in the science of learning.
May 7, 2025 at 6:07 PM
First, the obvious: faculty at colleges and universities are appointed based on their research, not the quality of their teaching. Most doctoral students receive little to no training in teaching, and the training they receive certainly isn’t evidence-based or situated in the science of learning.
Having said that, I can’t help but think about how poor the quality of teaching often is in higher education and hoping that this crisis might lead to better pedagogy.
May 7, 2025 at 6:07 PM
Having said that, I can’t help but think about how poor the quality of teaching often is in higher education and hoping that this crisis might lead to better pedagogy.
Also, I think we need to take seriously that the incentives for students are absolutely fucked. Especially at, say, Columbia University, the emphasis on grades is so overwhelming that even intellectually curious students with strong work ethics will be tempted to take these kinds of shortcuts.
May 7, 2025 at 6:07 PM
Also, I think we need to take seriously that the incentives for students are absolutely fucked. Especially at, say, Columbia University, the emphasis on grades is so overwhelming that even intellectually curious students with strong work ethics will be tempted to take these kinds of shortcuts.