Legendlord. Players are expected to make a version of themselves Legendlore: Legacies of Earth - Onyx Path Publishing | DriveThruRPG share.google/F6xTacwX7nXJ...

Maybe Liberal in the sense of Liberal Democratic government. I have mixed political opinions but I'm very pro Rule of Law and that only works with equality under the law

We are now at 6 color coded bats. Bruce is obviously Gray and hates it but doesn't argue because Damien came up with it and so the more he fights the worse it gets. Let's say Kate Kane moved to Metropolis and we'll let her and Maggie Sawyer have a happy ending. She now is on team Krpton

Nice. We could even have a plot where he runs for office. He loses and then reveals that the whole point was to see who would reveal themselves to try and bribe a billionaire.

Barbara is with Dick on the JL but not as a Bat. Taking a note from Created Equal she is Green Lantern. Red Canary also could be cool.

Lucius is tech Batman but also space Batman. When it goes down on another planet he's the one they send. Stephanie left the vigilante lifestyle and became Commissioner. Her nickname among criminals is "Spoiler" again.

Cassie is Batwoman and bounces between members also. "Black Bat" helped form their new codenames among the family. Dick/Blue, Jason/Red, Damien/Green, Lucius/Yellow.

Bruce spends some time raising Helena but then she becomes Robin. Bounces around the whole Bat family and Gotham academy. Is forming her own Titans group alongside Trinity Prince.

Tim is "Red Robin" technically sidekick to all of them but also field coordinator. "Dick this is a Magic thing, we need to call Damien". Is actually the one solving most of the mysteries.

Eleusis might fit this criteria. You see a set of playing cards and have to deduce the underlying pattern.

Whoops! Sorry about that

Not horror per se but Pauline Hopkins last novel Of One Blood includes gothic horror elements. More of a blended genre with gothic, adventure, thriller, social commentary, and sci-fi.