Center for Online Safety and Liberty
banner
c4osl.org
Center for Online Safety and Liberty
@c4osl.org
Empowering individuals and communities to thrive online by building safer spaces, fostering creativity, combating harm, and championing digital rights and freedom.

c4osl.org
Pinned
Hello Bluesky! We're a new nonprofit providing fiscal sponsorship for independent projects that promote online safety and liberty.

Our four priority areas are:

* Safer Hosting
* Supporting Fans
* Cyberbullying and Abuse
* Legal Advocacy

Read more on our website and spread the word!
"But conflating personal expression with abuse does not shield children; it shields policymakers from accountability. It substitutes moral panic for evidence and politics for public health." https://c4osl.org/december-2025-newsletter #FreeExpression #MoralPanic
Drawing the Line Watchlist 2025 - COSL Newsletter #9
c4osl.org
December 26, 2025 at 6:01 PM
Reposted by Center for Online Safety and Liberty
UK Law Enforcement Pushed Hard To Maintain Access To Deeply Flawed Facial Recognition Tech

While each iteration presents a chance to improve, there are some very real reasons why facial recognition tech will do a bit of stagnating. And that reason is the biggest market for this tech: law…
UK Law Enforcement Pushed Hard To Maintain Access To Deeply Flawed Facial Recognition Tech
While each iteration presents a chance to improve, there are some very real reasons why facial recognition tech will do a bit of stagnating. And that reason is the biggest market for this tech: law enforcement agencies. In 2019, the US National Institute for Science and Technology studied 189 different facial recognition algorithms. The results were conclusive: every single one of them performed worse when asked to "recognize" anything other than white male faces.
www.techdirt.com
December 24, 2025 at 11:42 PM
"Blurring the line legitimises the overstepping of human-rights boundaries, over-criminalises marginalised communities, and diverts resources from genuine child protection" https://c4osl.org/december-2025-newsletter #HumanRights #FreeExpression #ChildProtection
Drawing the Line Watchlist 2025 - COSL Newsletter #9
c4osl.org
December 25, 2025 at 6:02 PM
Reposted by Center for Online Safety and Liberty
Stopping non-consensual intimate imagery matters. But Congress’ attempt to address NCII misses the mark, and threatens speech and privacy in the process. eff.org/deeplinks/2...
December 24, 2025 at 7:57 PM
"Besides being harmful, treating fictional sexual content as equivalent to lived abuse is unjustified on any legitimate child-safety grounds." https://c4osl.org/december-2025-newsletter #FreeExpression #ChildSafety #FictionIsNotAbuse
Drawing the Line Watchlist 2025 - COSL Newsletter #9
c4osl.org
December 24, 2025 at 6:01 PM
"Just as children are not the beneficiaries of this conflation, its targets are not sex offenders, but more often artists, authors, LGBTQ+ communities, and even children themselves." https://c4osl.org/december-2025-newsletter #LGBTQ #FreeExpression
Drawing the Line Watchlist 2025 - COSL Newsletter #9
c4osl.org
December 23, 2025 at 6:02 PM
"The stakes for children, whose safety depends on precise and proportionate interventions, are high, but so too are the stakes for others when child-safety concerns are used to justify broad extension of state power." https://policyreview.info/articles/news/drawing-the-line-child-safety-laws/2058
Drawing the line: When child safety laws lose sight of real children
Newly released data reveal how a no-compromise approach to AI-generated and other fictional sexual content depicting children has diverted resources away from prosecuting real child sexual abuse material (CSAM).
policyreview.info
December 22, 2025 at 6:01 PM
"'This isn’t about obscenity,' Keri Lambert, vice president of the Rutherford County Library Alliance, told The Advocate in an interview. 'This is about eliminating the acknowledgment that LGBTQ+ people exist.'" https://www.advocate.com/news/tennessee-library-books-purge
Tennessee whistleblower says library board chair sought private data as part of state's book purge
A First Amendment expert told The Advocate that there are "huge" legal implications stemming from the situation.
www.advocate.com
December 21, 2025 at 6:02 PM
From last week's Drawing the Line webinar, arts advocate Emma Shapiro explains how child safety is being used as a pretext to censor visual arts online. Continue watching: https://c4osl.org/drawing-the-line-webinar #DrawingTheLine #ChildSafety #FreeExpression
December 20, 2025 at 8:02 PM
"For many young people, social media platforms are not simply entertainment. They are places of learning, authorship, peer support, political awakening, and cultural participation" https://www.techdirt.com/2025/12/17/when-the-internet-grew-up-and-locked-out-its-kids/
When The Internet Grew Up — And Locked Out Its Kids
In December 2025, the world crossed a threshold. For the first time ever, access to the major social media platforms was no longer guaranteed by interest, connection, or curiosity — but by a birth …
www.techdirt.com
December 20, 2025 at 6:01 PM
Reposted by Center for Online Safety and Liberty
Though age verification mandates claim to protect children, in practice they create harmful censorship and surveillance regimes that put everyone—adults and young people alike—at risk. Learn how to fight back at our new Age Verification Resource Center: EFF.org/Age.
Age Verification and Age Gating: Resource Hub
Age verification (or age-gating) laws generally require online services to check, estimate, or verify all users’ ages—often through invasive tools like ID checks, biometric scans, or other dubious
www.eff.org
December 19, 2025 at 8:00 PM
Reposted by Center for Online Safety and Liberty
NEW: They kept saying they were gonna do it and now they've done it

A group of clowns (Senators) have introduced a bill to FULLY REPEAL Section 230.

No reform, no replacement, just utter destruction of all online free speech.

We can't let this happen. Share & take action

www.badinternetbills.com
Bad Internet Bills
All of the bad internet bills. One website.
www.badinternetbills.com
December 18, 2025 at 7:37 PM
Reposted by Center for Online Safety and Liberty
A federal judge has blocked an age-verification mandate for social media in Louisiana, ruling that the same content can be accessed on unregulated sites, that it chills a huge amount of speech and that tools already exist for parents to block use.

You know, the same arguments FSC made in Paxton.
Louisiana’s age-check law for social media is unconstitutional, federal judge rules • Louisiana Illuminator
The Secure Online Child Interaction and Age Limitation Act calls for all social media sites with more than 5 million users to make “reasonable efforts” to obtain proof of age to establish an account.
lailluminator.com
December 18, 2025 at 8:07 PM
“Governments are redirecting resources from protecting children to policing expression.” — Jeremy Malcolm
Listen to the Watchlist episode:
-> https://c4osl.org/beyond-the-filter-drawing-the-line-watchlist/ #BeyondTheFilter #DrawingTheLine #FreeExpression
Beyond the Filter: Drawing the Line Watchlist - Center for Online Safety and Liberty
In this special edition of Beyond the Filter, hosts Brandy Brightman and Jeremy Malcolm present the global launch of the Drawing the […]
c4osl.org
December 19, 2025 at 6:01 PM
Reposted by Center for Online Safety and Liberty
2025 was the year millions of Americans awoke to the danger of state surveillance, violent policing, rights erasure, online censorship, ideological funding cancellations and retaliatory doxxing.

None of this was new to sex workers.

If there's not rights for everyone, there's rights for no one.
(1/3) Until s*x workers are safe, none of us are safe.

Tomorrow on #D17, International Day to End Violence Against S*x Workers, we honor the workers we've lost to violence and stand firm in our commitment to decriminalization.
December 18, 2025 at 12:23 AM
“From a linguistic lens, there are so few pieces of language that are in and of themselves harmful. It all depends on context.” — Zora Rush Hear more in this week’s Beyond the Filter:
-> https://c4osl.org/beyond-the-filter-drawing-the-line-watchlist/
Beyond the Filter: Drawing the Line Watchlist - Center for Online Safety and Liberty
In this special edition of Beyond the Filter, hosts Brandy Brightman and Jeremy Malcolm present the global launch of the Drawing the […]
c4osl.org
December 18, 2025 at 6:00 PM
“There was that inherent linkage to child sexual abuse material under the Australian law and trans and gender diverse people, which I found a really ironic linkage between the two.” — Ashley Remminga
Full episode:
-> https://c4osl.org/beyond-the-filter-drawing-the-line-watchlist/ #BeyondTheFilter
ERROR 520
c4osl.org
December 17, 2025 at 6:02 PM
Reposted by Center for Online Safety and Liberty
Indiana just sued Pornhub under the state’s AV law, claiming it fails to block Indianans from using VPNs to access the site.

Indiana wrote a bad law that they were warned was grossly ineffective, and rather than admit it or fix it, they’re blaming porn sites.
Indiana Sues Aylo for Violating AV Law by Not Blocking VPN Use AVN
Indiana Attorney General Todd Rokita, a Republican, announced today that his office sued Aylo, its affiliated companies, and the ownership group Ethical Capital Partners for allegedly violating the st...
avn.com
December 15, 2025 at 10:55 PM
“We’re dealing with a moral panic that’s been escalating for a long time.” — Emma Shapiro
New Beyond the Filter episode on the Watchlist:
-> https://c4osl.org/beyond-the-filter-drawing-the-line-watchlist/ #BeyondTheFilter #DrawingTheLine #FreeExpression #MoralPanic
Beyond the Filter: Drawing the Line Watchlist - Center for Online Safety and Liberty
In this special edition of Beyond the Filter, hosts Brandy Brightman and Jeremy Malcolm present the global launch of the Drawing the […]
c4osl.org
December 16, 2025 at 6:02 PM
Reposted by Center for Online Safety and Liberty
The latest patch for the disastrous Online Safety Act? A "nudity blocker" installed on all UK devices.

The OSA was supposed to protect kids online, but was so vaguely defined and unenforceable that the UK keeps inventing new, ever more invasive tools, like "nudity filters" and VPN bans as cover.
UK Wants All iPhones to Block Explicit Images Unless You Prove Age
Apple and Google will soon be "encouraged" to build nudity-detection algorithms into their software by default, as part of the UK government's strategy to tackle violence against women and girls, repo...
www.macrumors.com
December 15, 2025 at 5:42 PM
Reposted by Center for Online Safety and Liberty
Not only does it trivialize the experience of lived abuse to equate it with art and fiction, but doing so also unequivocally violates international human rights law, which limits criminal penalties to preventing or punishing conduct that causes real and identifiable harm.
December 15, 2025 at 6:17 PM
“... the legal systems in most of those countries are blurring the line between personal expression.” — Jeremy Malcolm
Hear the full Watchlist breakdown on Beyond the Filter:
-> https://c4osl.org/beyond-the-filter-drawing-the-line-watchlist/ #BeyondTheFilter #DrawingTheLine #FreeExpression
Beyond the Filter: Drawing the Line Watchlist - Center for Online Safety and Liberty
In this special edition of Beyond the Filter, hosts Brandy Brightman and Jeremy Malcolm present the global launch of the Drawing the […]
c4osl.org
December 15, 2025 at 6:03 PM
Reposted by Center for Online Safety and Liberty
“And finally, the assault on Section 230. This is the endgame for independent speech.

If you repeal 230, you don’t hurt Google or Meta—they have the lawyers to survive. You destroy the small forums, the independent blogs, the dissenters. You make the cost of speaking the truth too high to bear.”
There’s a specific mechanism in authoritarian movements that we’re seeing play out in real-time across American media and tech. It’s a simple rule: "If we cannot co-opt it, we must destroy it."

It is the logic of "scorched earth." It's the logic of the Nero Decree and it's happening right now. 🧵
December 14, 2025 at 9:15 PM
"Governments in the U.S. and around the world are increasingly adopting these restrictive measures in the name of protecting children online. But in practice, these systems create dangerous new forms of surveillance, censorship, and exclusion." https://www.eff.org/issues/age-verification
Age Verification and Age Gating: Resource Hub
Age verification (or age-gating) laws generally require online services to check, estimate, or verify all users’ ages—often through invasive tools like ID checks, biometric scans, or other dubious “age estimation” methods—before granting them access to certain online content or services.  Governments in the U.S. and around the world are increasingly adopting these restrictive measures in the name of protecting children online. But in practice, these systems create dangerous new forms of surveillance, censorship, and exclusion.  Technologically, the age verification process can take many forms: collection and analysis of government ID, biometric scans, algorithmic or AI-based behavioral or user monitoring, digital ID, the list goes on. But no matter the method, every system demands users hand over sensitive and immutable personal information that links their offline identity to their online activity. Once that valuable data is collected, it can easily be leaked, hacked, or misused. (Indeed, we’ve already seen several breaches of age verification providers.) EFF has long warned against age-gating the internet. Age verification technology itself is often inaccurate and privacy-invasive. These restrictive mandates strike at the foundation of the free and open internet. They are tools of censorship, used to block people from viewing or sharing information that the government deems “harmful” or “offensive.” And they create surveillance systems that critically undermine online privacy, chill access to vital online communities and resources, and burden the expressive rights of adults and young people alike. EFF.org/Age: A Resource to Empower Users Age-gating mandates are reshaping the internet in ways that are invasive, dangerous, and deeply unnecessary. But users are not powerless! We can challenge these laws, protect our digital rights, and build a safer digital world for all internet users, no matter their ages. This resource hub is here to help—so explore, share, and join us in the fight for a better internet.
www.eff.org
December 14, 2025 at 8:02 PM
Reposted by Center for Online Safety and Liberty
Guys you can't ban VPN for kids without ALSO severely restricting the ability of adults to use VPNs without surveillance.

If this were proposed in Saudi Arabia or Myanmar or Hungary or Belarus, the British government would rightly call this what it is: a mandate for censorship.
UK Lords propose ban on VPNs for children
Amendment to the Children's Wellbeing and Schools Bill would force VPN providers to age-gate their services
www.techradar.com
December 13, 2025 at 9:14 PM