So that's one of the reasons I can't buy Carol or Rudy Knight (among other reasons) because we've seen them in the light world. This leaves only Dess and Asriel (not my favorite but can't dispute it on this point) as choices for me, as we haven't seen them in the light world

My personal theory is the k right is just kinda like that, given how the black shard is real in the light world, unless whoever is wielding and potentially wearing a lot of strong opaque glass, I feel that the knight aint a transformation, but just how they are(1/2)

That being red( i assume red is determination), which allows her to come back from death a few tiems before dying. Also as you can tell she is a lot more ferocious and monstrous, thats because when the game describes a monster with a human souls as a horrible beast, which i took inspiration from.

So my thought process with this was that monsters are weaker then humans as they arent as physically strong, as well as having weaker souls, so this form changes that, im exchange for weaker magic(can only use 1 spear at a time) undyne is physically stronger and has gained a soul trait(1/?)

To be fair to casual people who think its carol, you can explore the town before entering the dark world giving her hypothetical time, unlike I who heard go to toriel and assumed going down would be safe

Thats fair, i think some stuff can be a bit far-fetched too

Ehh I think it's fine, it's not like there is any harm to it unless people take it too seriously, and it's fun to hear ideas. I mean I remember several delta theories with weird thumbnails that were pretty good or at least fun