Then, there were covers used by Dingo in CZW (by Nonpoint), Mark Ross in KAOS Wrestling (by STATE of MINE), and Ashton Day in Circle 6 (by The Protomen, in edited form) but that's another story.

It was also used by Cameron Saturn in 2022. I have Saturn using it in Next Level Soldiers promoted show and the TransGraps show but in edited form as the song starts when the drums kick in.

I still have an audio recording but Awful's entrance goes for less than a minute before the drum kicking in part - drive.google.com/file/d/10g84...

The Phil Collins song was used once by Kerry Awful in Bizarro Lucha's 2019.02.10 show. Unfortunately, there's no footage on YouTube but the whole show is on IWTV.

The bad news is that he's a face and comes out when the drums kicks in though there were times were he used "In the Air Tonight" as an intro for other themes Ross used as seen here:

youtu.be/J4K9aV52UOs?...
youtu.be/cOj0lVG2gzg?...

So, I guess that meets half of your criteria.