I never argued against money? What? I was talking about the bourgeois framing of things

A pension system more or less, like how the USSR had or Hoxha’s Albania. It also depends on what stage of the socialist revolution the state is in

What? What the fuck are you talking about? A house which is not for profit is not private property even if hypothetically it could be rented out? What?

Capital is an analysis of capitalism? Is this news to you?

God damn I hate how liberals are so condescending

Capitalism is progressive when compared to feudalism, but socialism is progressive when compared to capitalism. I mean this in the class sense of that word

That’s the petty bourgeoisie. A house is personal property not private property

That is the Marxist definition. A proletarian is a person which does not own private property and in capitalism must sell their labor power as a commodity

When did I say that? Again purposeful misunderstanding

You said “elderly and children shouldn’t be workers” while misunderstanding the term I was using. I then explained why the way you’re using that term is not the same as when I say it. You disregard that. That seems like you purposefully misunderstanding me

The masses and democracy, there is freedom in discussion but unity of action.

Opportunity cost, return on investment, etc. This is still the framework of markets and not a planned economy

This says nothing about starving the peasants to feed the industrial proletariat

No? When did I do that?

Ancient Sparta…..had money?

Socialism isn’t “When no currency” currency will exist in one form or another until there is no more private property. The NEP was necessary because socialism emerges out of capitalism, and capitalism out of feudalism, so they had to develop the industry to advance

Trump is a Stalinist dictator. Are you gonna say that?

That was what the Kulak’s did lmao. A famine is a natural occurrence, it killed more Russians and Kazakhs than Ukrainians. No one is saying it isn’t unfortunate, but the famine was not man made