Dammit I forgot pro wrestling. Put it at 5 and bump everything down.

Appreciate you asking DiManno for her rationale, even though it’s nonsensical. Schneider made egregious pitching decisions that cost them wins yet she still had him second? And I bet you have to look hard to find Guardians fans ripping lots of Vogt’s decisions.

A Marty York comparison? That’s a scathing statement! 🤣

But yeah why DiManno gets a vote when she is a baseball dilettante at best is beyond me. Lots of other baseball writers in Toronto.

Bruce Arthur, as good of a writer as he is, is also part time on sports these days. It’s possible Mike Wilner voted on a different award. Baseball writers only vote for one award each year, and each city with an MLB team gets two votes per award.