We report a divergent electrochemical strategy for the bioinspired synthesis of mavacurane- and akuammiline-type alkaloid frameworks from a common indole–malonate precursor. By tuning the redox mediator, selective N–C or C–C bond formation was achieved. Iodide-mediated electrolysis promoted iodination of the malonate carbanion, followed by intramolecular nucleophilic cyclization to furnish the mavacurane core. In contrast, ferrocene-mediated oxidation generated a malonate-centered radical that afforded the akuammiline skeleton.