Head of the Federmann School of public policy 2017-2021
Vice Dean of Teaching, Faculty of Social Sciences
🧠 Compromise effect: Temporary laws seem like a "middle ground."
🏛️ Status quo bias: Once a law exists, people prefer to keep it.
🔄 Ratchet effect: Temporary laws often get extended rather than repealed.
🧠 Compromise effect: Temporary laws seem like a "middle ground."
🏛️ Status quo bias: Once a law exists, people prefer to keep it.
🔄 Ratchet effect: Temporary laws often get extended rather than repealed.
USA PATRIOT Act (2001): Originally temporary, but many provisions remain.
State of emergency laws in France: Post-2015 terror attacks, later made permanent.
COVID-19 policies: Some surveillance measures still in use today.
USA PATRIOT Act (2001): Originally temporary, but many provisions remain.
State of emergency laws in France: Post-2015 terror attacks, later made permanent.
COVID-19 policies: Some surveillance measures still in use today.
Temporary laws can erode resistance to rights restrictions. Once enacted, they become easier to extend—eventually leading to permanent policy shifts.
The "sunset clause paradox": Laws meant to expire tend to stick around.
Temporary laws can erode resistance to rights restrictions. Once enacted, they become easier to extend—eventually leading to permanent policy shifts.
The "sunset clause paradox": Laws meant to expire tend to stick around.
When given multiple options (temporary vs. permanent), most chose temporary.
However, once a policy was in place, people were more likely to extend it than approve a new one.
Status quo bias at work. 🔁
When given multiple options (temporary vs. permanent), most chose temporary.
However, once a policy was in place, people were more likely to extend it than approve a new one.
Status quo bias at work. 🔁
Even people who initially rejected the policy were more willing to approve it if framed as temporary.
This suggests policymakers can use "temporary" framing to push through controversial policies.
Even people who initially rejected the policy were more willing to approve it if framed as temporary.
This suggests policymakers can use "temporary" framing to push through controversial policies.
Participants were asked whether they approve a policy allowing harsh interrogation techniques.
Some saw it as temporary, others as permanent.
Those who saw it as temporary were more likely to approve it!
Participants were asked whether they approve a policy allowing harsh interrogation techniques.
Some saw it as temporary, others as permanent.
Those who saw it as temporary were more likely to approve it!
To find out, we conducted 3behavioral experiments. 🧪📊
To find out, we conducted 3behavioral experiments. 🧪📊
Examples:
🦠 COVID-19 restrictions
🛂 Counterterrorism laws
👮 Surveillance measures
But do these policies remain temporary, or do they become the new normal? 🤔
Examples:
🦠 COVID-19 restrictions
🛂 Counterterrorism laws
👮 Surveillance measures
But do these policies remain temporary, or do they become the new normal? 🤔
www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1...
www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1...
osf.io/preprints/os...
7/7
osf.io/preprints/os...
7/7
6/7>>
6/7>>
5/7>>
5/7>>
4/7>>
4/7>>
3/7>>
3/7>>