I keep getting mails of my co-authors asking me what I did - on the other hand, the ACs response was kind. I was flagged automatically apparently… harsh for public shaming
NeurIPS for a paper providing no algorithm, no theory, no data, no analysis... it is simply an opinionated, colloquial review. I said as much. Instead of looking at it, the AC forced me to add to my review, threatening to reject papers of my co-authors.
I keep getting mails of my co-authors asking me what I did - on the other hand, the ACs response was kind. I was flagged automatically apparently… harsh for public shaming