I like this theory but it seemed like all the monsters were people from the Anghkooey kids' time? I assumed it was a really long time ago so could he really be a driver? 🤔 orrrr it hints that sacrifices were not made just one time and monsters are from different times

Idk I dare to hope no one would agree to turn into such a thing just to live longer lol

100% I don't think they're human anymore but can they still hold on to memories? Or doubt their choice? They sure look happy about this but idk, remember how Jasmine told Kevin she didn't chose to be this way?

If the day wasn't be crazy enough now this guy gets brutally murderer in the wood during the day and everyone has to be on high alert bc that's what directly threaten them

Bc the only witness is the Julie from the future and I don't think he ever told her about the voice he heard and what was said to him + I doubt she'd remember MIY's words with how traumatizing the scene is for her

I remember someone online suggesting that he was the driver of the school bus or a truck that landed in #FROM ville. I like that idea. =)

MIY sold their original human selves on immortality, but was he up front about the Monster-ness?

They really do seem happy, tho, right? Makes me think they’re like BUFFY vamps—transformed, and true to their nature, not humans trapped in another form.

#FROM

Wait that's such a good question, it would be crazy if they could take any appearance 😱 hoping s4 comes soon and brings us more infos!

Unless they address it again this moment will forever bug me too! But they tend to manipulate people (like grandma and Meagan) so it could have been that too?
It would be insane if newcomers could be turn into monsters too bc as far as we know it was the Abghkooey kids' parent who were turned!

I always go back to the first night when the Matthews came & that one boy said “Don’t you remember me Julie?” and she looked like she was remembering him. As time went on I was like “Did he end up there after a trip or was it a plot hole?” If he did, I think a part of the human in them misses it.

Yeah I remember him telling Boyd about it! But I don't know if it's memories, like I remember one using the swing and idk if there was something like that when they got turned?

I think they just try to live again the things they remember from when they were humans.

In an episode, Randall talks about their habits, which they repeat every night. I think these habits are things they remember they liked to do when they were human.

And many of them wear clothes and accessories that don't seem to match the time period in which they were turned, so did they get attach to these at some point, or like to experiment with their victim's stuff..? Do they carry memories and trinkets in their bags and pockets?

I keep thinking about Smiley, the way he observes everything inside Colony House, caresses the plants, how he sits and almost plays in the bus... what IS going on in his head...

We know Miranda had visions/flashes from her previous lives but it doesn't mean she knew who the kids were... I need to rewatch again with this in mind lolol

I mean, Tabitha did go through the tree, and it "only" helped her get her memories back. The children haven't been saved 🤔

Oohh forgot about Donna shooting the tires! He had the keys bc he can turn up the lights and I'd say the windows are high enough not to be damaged (I could be wrong) but the tires are definitely off, you're right!