Maybe we have more in common on this than short statements will reveal, I share some of your concerns but we have nothing to go on other than self report when people are telling us about how their clothes make them feel (for example) and I think we need to be careful not to discount that...
June 20, 2025 at 6:39 AM
Maybe we have more in common on this than short statements will reveal, I share some of your concerns but we have nothing to go on other than self report when people are telling us about how their clothes make them feel (for example) and I think we need to be careful not to discount that...
Ah yes, okay, with you on that. Don't worry, I'm not recommending VARK (can no longer even remember what the R stood for!!) But 'voice of the child' still usually pretty central for me but with clear caveats around APDR and a good dose of common sense / evidence based practice too!!
June 3, 2025 at 7:44 PM
Ah yes, okay, with you on that. Don't worry, I'm not recommending VARK (can no longer even remember what the R stood for!!) But 'voice of the child' still usually pretty central for me but with clear caveats around APDR and a good dose of common sense / evidence based practice too!!
To be fair, I will support most things a child says they think will help! So maybe this is why I feel uneasy here. When they're saying "This helps" and I'm saying "No it doesn't".
June 3, 2025 at 7:27 PM
To be fair, I will support most things a child says they think will help! So maybe this is why I feel uneasy here. When they're saying "This helps" and I'm saying "No it doesn't".
To clarify, I've never recommended them, but then nor have I ever really discouraged them if they are already in use. I have shared my understanding of the research though. You've made me think on this again though, thank you.
To clarify, I've never recommended them, but then nor have I ever really discouraged them if they are already in use. I have shared my understanding of the research though. You've made me think on this again though, thank you.
And if we accept their use as a placebo do we reduce the likelihood of them receiving the right support to develop their reading skills and the support they need to reduce that barrier in the classroom?
June 3, 2025 at 7:10 PM
And if we accept their use as a placebo do we reduce the likelihood of them receiving the right support to develop their reading skills and the support they need to reduce that barrier in the classroom?
I grapple with this. Children tell me that the overlay helps them. Research evidence tells me that it doesn't and I'm not sure I've ever landed on a satisfactory response in this situation.
I grapple with this. Children tell me that the overlay helps them. Research evidence tells me that it doesn't and I'm not sure I've ever landed on a satisfactory response in this situation.
I really enjoyed hearing you speak on this today and it gave me lots to think about - thank you. I think you mentioned a study (from King's College maybe) where students self referred for small group MH intervention - did I hear that right? Could you maybe point me in right the direction?
April 1, 2025 at 6:48 PM
I really enjoyed hearing you speak on this today and it gave me lots to think about - thank you. I think you mentioned a study (from King's College maybe) where students self referred for small group MH intervention - did I hear that right? Could you maybe point me in right the direction?
We are also looking to develop a stand alone session too, but also need to make sure everything we do / say is neuroaffirming. Do you mind me asking if you created the session from scratch? I couldn't find anything on the ELSA Network forum
February 17, 2025 at 7:26 PM
We are also looking to develop a stand alone session too, but also need to make sure everything we do / say is neuroaffirming. Do you mind me asking if you created the session from scratch? I couldn't find anything on the ELSA Network forum