I leaned towards Judge’s dominance in every category and valued that above Raleigh, even when I considered catching.

I do think there’s some “Judge exhaustion” among voters with an assumption we won’t remember this season from Judge… but he’s in one of the most dominant stretches in MLB history

Please be a serious person.

Oh thanks Joe Kickass I wish I had this information prior.

And that’s what I call “Judge exhaustion”, which I had to try to keep out of my selection process to view this as one individual season.

Terribly difficult decision that took a lot of time, but Judge’s season was historic (again) and just narrowly tilted it for me. Two elite years and elite players