"I like it a lot." He would insist, a light chuckle to himself. Tony was always so nice to him...
...
"A-ah..?" He would lost in thought, almost too much, before realising what Tony did. Maybe he felt a bit flustered to give a response... Blushing a bit
At least the reaction didn't seem negative...?

"I'm Jeff. .. Nice to meet you, then, Alex."

"Oh, really?" A little pause... he.. genuinely forgot about the holiday because of how into working on things he was.
He feels a bit silly.
"It's really quite cute.. Thank you, Tony."
He's going to have to quickly put something together later..

"Tony, hello! Is something wrong? Or did you just wish to chat?"

"Indeed I am. And you are...?"

"Oh! Yes! Those. They're very good." He said with a gentle nod. Taking the cookies, "Thank you very much, Tony."

"Do you have any of those ones which resemble a checkerboard? The name slips my mind... I know the dark quadrants are chocolate, though."

"Ah, a snack? I could go for one if you're having them, too. ..You don't happen to have any cookies, do you?"

Totally. Completely. Jeff is oblivious for the most part anyhow, so it's just a friend thing. The hug would feel rather affectionate, but Jeff took it as 'Tony being Tony', and didn't mind it.

"Oh! Well, that's alright with me."
Of course. they ARE best friends, right? Cue a hug from Jeff to Tony.

("Are you ready for an excited gay boy?", my friend asks me. Lol)

"Hello, Tony. Is there something you need?"

I'm not very strong, really near-sighted, kind of shy, and I tend to be a little reckless. This is just the way I am...