jazakallahu khayr for the correction
June 9, 2025 at 10:55 PM
jazakallahu khayr for the correction
it might be a blocker for takfir but it may be problematic to apply consistently
i.e someone invoking an idol cannot use the occasionalist/independent copout because making du'a to an idol is unrestrictedly kufr regardless of intent
more on this
islamicdiscourse.substack.com/p/clarifying...
i.e someone invoking an idol cannot use the occasionalist/independent copout because making du'a to an idol is unrestrictedly kufr regardless of intent
islamicdiscourse.substack.com/p/clarifying...
Islamic Discourse on Islamic Discourse
Assalamu Alaykum,
Despite my disagreement with occassionalism, I am worried about leaving people with the impression that this reprehensible istiqlal/independence stance makes sense within the occas...
open.substack.com
December 22, 2024 at 1:58 PM
it might be a blocker for takfir but it may be problematic to apply consistently
i.e someone invoking an idol cannot use the occasionalist/independent copout because making du'a to an idol is unrestrictedly kufr regardless of intent
more on this
islamicdiscourse.substack.com/p/clarifying...
i.e someone invoking an idol cannot use the occasionalist/independent copout because making du'a to an idol is unrestrictedly kufr regardless of intent
islamicdiscourse.substack.com/p/clarifying...
many of those who speak in support of istighatha don't seem to be aware of the differences in their own tradition either
December 22, 2024 at 1:59 AM
many of those who speak in support of istighatha don't seem to be aware of the differences in their own tradition either
some istighatha proponents of today use a new argument
one can ask any created being for a request
as long as they believe Allah is the sole doer of everything.
basically justifying istighatha through hard ash'ari occasionalism
subki et al justified on the basis of metaphor for tawassul
one can ask any created being for a request
as long as they believe Allah is the sole doer of everything.
basically justifying istighatha through hard ash'ari occasionalism
subki et al justified on the basis of metaphor for tawassul
December 22, 2024 at 1:57 AM
some istighatha proponents of today use a new argument
one can ask any created being for a request
as long as they believe Allah is the sole doer of everything.
basically justifying istighatha through hard ash'ari occasionalism
subki et al justified on the basis of metaphor for tawassul
one can ask any created being for a request
as long as they believe Allah is the sole doer of everything.
basically justifying istighatha through hard ash'ari occasionalism
subki et al justified on the basis of metaphor for tawassul