Same for me and also got 2 resubmissions from my NeurIPS batch 🙂

As I currently work with him, I can say with certainty that Cassio is in the middle

In my experience a discussion works well. In a lot of my papers we were able to have a discussion with the reviewers and get our scores up. Many tines there was no change as well but I still prefer a nice discussion over a mere button click.

Well that is also true. 😁

A nice idea would be to have the acknowledgement along with some sort of justification

I know that. My point is that clicking a button is useless and most reviewers will not engage. In our case reviewers asked for experiments, we provide them and people just click the acknowledgement button without any accountability. As an AC, in my batch at least some reviewers are engaging

Yes but at least they had to write something on their own and we could engage with them.

Congratulations!! This is an amazing work

Very interesting!! Sorry won't be able to make it to the poster but will definitely look at the work in more detail