Alastor is a fluffy! (Mouse!)

Oooh! Inject this angst into my VEINS!

I love how it looks like Alastor is luring Lucifer out of bed with coffee. Follow the coffee to the kitchen Lu.

... ignorance was bliss

Huh, I never heard that one. It makes no sense to me.

Has the theory been around long, or is it relatively new? Who is the someone else Lucifer supposedly had Charlie with?

She's the daughter of the first fallen angel, and the first woman turned succubus demon.

I don't think anyone could consider her an average Hellborn. Especially with her borderline angelic behaviour.

I think Lucifer would use angelic power to create life, not dark magic. Using Liliths essence would cause red blood.

I do agree that Lilith is 100% Charlie's mum. There's nothing in canon to indicate otherwise, after all.

Everything else is just fanon ideas that could make sense in an AU.

In canon, though, I'm certain Lilith gave birth to Charlie. I've heard and seen nothing in canon to indicate otherwise.

I'd say, "If I'm wrong, I'll eat my hat," but it's a nice hat, and I'm not a goat.

If we're talking hypothetical of Lilith impregnating Lucifer once. I imagine they just swapped equipment, so to speak, for the purpose of procreation, and then switched back.

Lilith could've been cursed to have trouble with fertility. Lucifer, though, could take her essence and work with it.

As for the one child in a 10,000 year relationship, I think a magical means of birth control. Either that or they had trouble conceiving, and Charlie was a miracle.

Lilith isn't a regular sinner. She fell to Hell with Lucifer when she was alive and transformed into a succubus demon. It's plausible that Lilith birthed Charlie.

That or Lucifer combined a bit of her essence with his own and popped a baby into existence with the snap of his fingers.

No, the theory is that Lilith impregnated Lucifer through magical angelic means.

I don't consider it a theory cause there's no real evidence in canon for it. It's more of an AU idea people play with in fiction.

His first creation looks so happy, too... 😢

I feel so awful for his first creation. Poor dear😞