PJay Malarxist
@brashcommie.bsky.social
🏳️🌈🚩 I exist. At least my mind thinks I do. But it also thinks a lot of stupid things.
Why? Is my favorite question. Not enough people ask it. They are unenlightened. Always ask it.
I recommend you follow @cityoftea916.bsky.social 👀
Why? Is my favorite question. Not enough people ask it. They are unenlightened. Always ask it.
I recommend you follow @cityoftea916.bsky.social 👀
What if the 10-year-old has a growth spurt and is 6 feet tall. Do we kick him out? What if the adult is 5 foot three and doesn’t have much muscle mass? It’s all arbitrary.
November 7, 2025 at 4:38 PM
What if the 10-year-old has a growth spurt and is 6 feet tall. Do we kick him out? What if the adult is 5 foot three and doesn’t have much muscle mass? It’s all arbitrary.
…overlap between men and women. And thus no reason why they should ever compete. Which is bullshit.
November 7, 2025 at 4:36 PM
…overlap between men and women. And thus no reason why they should ever compete. Which is bullshit.
The argument goes, men and women can’t compete with each other. (Not saying this is your argument this is just the general premises of this argument.) Then it says trans women are men so it’s unfair if they compete with biological women. This would have to assume that there is no physical ability…
November 7, 2025 at 4:36 PM
The argument goes, men and women can’t compete with each other. (Not saying this is your argument this is just the general premises of this argument.) Then it says trans women are men so it’s unfair if they compete with biological women. This would have to assume that there is no physical ability…
I am very much about dealing in reality. I think men and women can compete coed. Yeah there are outliers. But the reality is that that is what sports is all about. Outliers. So acting like they are uniquely impossible to be near each other is a very misogynist viewpoint.
November 7, 2025 at 4:34 PM
I am very much about dealing in reality. I think men and women can compete coed. Yeah there are outliers. But the reality is that that is what sports is all about. Outliers. So acting like they are uniquely impossible to be near each other is a very misogynist viewpoint.
…a large overlap of physical characteristics which allow them to be evenly matched when it comes to sports. So the notion that men and women can never compete (the basis of much transphobia against trans women) is largely not supported by science.
November 7, 2025 at 4:33 PM
…a large overlap of physical characteristics which allow them to be evenly matched when it comes to sports. So the notion that men and women can never compete (the basis of much transphobia against trans women) is largely not supported by science.
Sorry. Lots of cutting and pasting to fit in character limits. The overlap is the shared physical characteristics of men and women. Specifically when talking about physical ability. Just as this chat shows heights have overlap where both share similar characteristics. Similarly men and women share…
November 7, 2025 at 4:33 PM
Sorry. Lots of cutting and pasting to fit in character limits. The overlap is the shared physical characteristics of men and women. Specifically when talking about physical ability. Just as this chat shows heights have overlap where both share similar characteristics. Similarly men and women share…
…experiences.
But the reality is that currently there is categorization. So until we get to that point Acting like there is no categorization just erases people’s identities that they feel strongly about. Which then ostracizes them from participation in the majority of culture.
But the reality is that currently there is categorization. So until we get to that point Acting like there is no categorization just erases people’s identities that they feel strongly about. Which then ostracizes them from participation in the majority of culture.
November 7, 2025 at 4:29 PM
…experiences.
But the reality is that currently there is categorization. So until we get to that point Acting like there is no categorization just erases people’s identities that they feel strongly about. Which then ostracizes them from participation in the majority of culture.
But the reality is that currently there is categorization. So until we get to that point Acting like there is no categorization just erases people’s identities that they feel strongly about. Which then ostracizes them from participation in the majority of culture.
…overlap. That men and women’s physical abilities are uniquely independent of each other. Which is completely devoid of scientific backing.
Personally, I would love for no categorization. Categorization is a shortcut that erases the differences between people and is reductive of people’s…
Personally, I would love for no categorization. Categorization is a shortcut that erases the differences between people and is reductive of people’s…
November 7, 2025 at 4:29 PM
…overlap. That men and women’s physical abilities are uniquely independent of each other. Which is completely devoid of scientific backing.
Personally, I would love for no categorization. Categorization is a shortcut that erases the differences between people and is reductive of people’s…
Personally, I would love for no categorization. Categorization is a shortcut that erases the differences between people and is reductive of people’s…
…them so they had to make their own sports. I can’t think of anything more misogynist than that.
And people like you bought into it. Bought into the notion that women couldn’t compete with men. And also bought into this biological bullshit about the fact that there is no crossover that there is no…
And people like you bought into it. Bought into the notion that women couldn’t compete with men. And also bought into this biological bullshit about the fact that there is no crossover that there is no…
November 7, 2025 at 4:29 PM
…them so they had to make their own sports. I can’t think of anything more misogynist than that.
And people like you bought into it. Bought into the notion that women couldn’t compete with men. And also bought into this biological bullshit about the fact that there is no crossover that there is no…
And people like you bought into it. Bought into the notion that women couldn’t compete with men. And also bought into this biological bullshit about the fact that there is no crossover that there is no…
Actually your premise that men and women have no crossover between their physical abilities and thus the arbitrary categorization of “men’s sports“” women’s sports“ is largely pointless.
And that categorization was only really done because women wanted to enter men’s sports and men wouldn’t allow…
And that categorization was only really done because women wanted to enter men’s sports and men wouldn’t allow…
November 7, 2025 at 4:29 PM
Actually your premise that men and women have no crossover between their physical abilities and thus the arbitrary categorization of “men’s sports“” women’s sports“ is largely pointless.
And that categorization was only really done because women wanted to enter men’s sports and men wouldn’t allow…
And that categorization was only really done because women wanted to enter men’s sports and men wouldn’t allow…
Love ad hominems
November 7, 2025 at 4:19 PM
Love ad hominems
And as long as you keep treating the two as wholly biologically based. It will continue to be held back.
November 7, 2025 at 4:18 PM
And as long as you keep treating the two as wholly biologically based. It will continue to be held back.
Agreed. And trans women aren’t men. They’re women. What you mean is you need female only spaces. But you’re purposely avoiding that term because you understand that that is biologically reductive. But you have no issue applying it to trans women who you identify as male.
November 7, 2025 at 4:17 PM
Agreed. And trans women aren’t men. They’re women. What you mean is you need female only spaces. But you’re purposely avoiding that term because you understand that that is biologically reductive. But you have no issue applying it to trans women who you identify as male.
So then you agree that biological females can socially identify as men and biological males can socially identify as women. Appreciate that.
November 7, 2025 at 4:15 PM
So then you agree that biological females can socially identify as men and biological males can socially identify as women. Appreciate that.
…female when it comes to physicality…this the overlap.
November 7, 2025 at 4:13 PM
…female when it comes to physicality…this the overlap.
What do you mean the same for all sports? I was talking about the physicality of women and men. There is loads of overlap. Or do you not believe that women can be 6 feet tall? Or men 5’3”. That is one of the measures of physicality and how there is a broad range that encompasses both male and…
November 7, 2025 at 4:13 PM
What do you mean the same for all sports? I was talking about the physicality of women and men. There is loads of overlap. Or do you not believe that women can be 6 feet tall? Or men 5’3”. That is one of the measures of physicality and how there is a broad range that encompasses both male and…
Actually it was a play on Joe Biden using the term malarkey and people calling him a communist when he clearly isn’t.
November 7, 2025 at 4:12 PM
Actually it was a play on Joe Biden using the term malarkey and people calling him a communist when he clearly isn’t.
And you’re just bigots who don’t care about science.
November 7, 2025 at 4:11 PM
And you’re just bigots who don’t care about science.
…people. Only by weight in some sports. But there are plenty of women who could beat men and plenty of men who couldn’t beat women regardless of their trans or cis status.
November 7, 2025 at 12:21 AM
…people. Only by weight in some sports. But there are plenty of women who could beat men and plenty of men who couldn’t beat women regardless of their trans or cis status.