I’m with you. The defense is already taking a step back, there’s the plantar fasciitis issue, he’s had some neck issues. None of that is going to get better. He’s not good enough offensively to become a future DH.

Not as good as Semien. Semien just won a gold glove. Has better range, and the bat is significantly better.

I’d love Tucker, I think Bellinger is more likely because of the versatility.

Defense, defense, defense.

Semiens range is drastically better than Acunas, and his bat is significantly better.

I get not liking the trade. I don’t think it’s great, but I don’t think it’s horrendous. I’m more curious if losing some offense increases the likelihood of Alonso coming back.

Nimmo is already a negative defensively, Semien just won a gold glove. That’s the reason for the move. Semiens contract is also up 2 years before Nimmos.