AlphaBenson
@alphabenson.bsky.social
After all, Reach was different, very obviously "grittier", "tacticool", and the fanbase ate it up. But it wasn't really true to what Halo ever was, except perhaps Halo 2 which had similar aspirations, albeit without picatinny rails.
November 3, 2025 at 3:30 PM
After all, Reach was different, very obviously "grittier", "tacticool", and the fanbase ate it up. But it wasn't really true to what Halo ever was, except perhaps Halo 2 which had similar aspirations, albeit without picatinny rails.
I honestly dont think people disliked the Reclaimer Saga art style because it was different-- I think they disliked it because they disliked it, but they could root their opinions in something more objective by pointing out the fact that it was different.
But if you liked it I dont think you'd care
But if you liked it I dont think you'd care
November 3, 2025 at 3:28 PM
I honestly dont think people disliked the Reclaimer Saga art style because it was different-- I think they disliked it because they disliked it, but they could root their opinions in something more objective by pointing out the fact that it was different.
But if you liked it I dont think you'd care
But if you liked it I dont think you'd care
More so I'm arguing AGAINST the idea that every game in the franchise needs to look the same, as if you wouldn't recognize an assault rifle or an Elite if they weren't the same asset as the previous game or in the same style.
I think if the creator has a vision, it's fine to reinterpret the visuals
I think if the creator has a vision, it's fine to reinterpret the visuals
November 3, 2025 at 3:21 PM
More so I'm arguing AGAINST the idea that every game in the franchise needs to look the same, as if you wouldn't recognize an assault rifle or an Elite if they weren't the same asset as the previous game or in the same style.
I think if the creator has a vision, it's fine to reinterpret the visuals
I think if the creator has a vision, it's fine to reinterpret the visuals
When did I ever state that no game should ever pursue photo realism? I just said it has the issue of appearing impressive for the time, but quickly losing its luster as techniques and technologies improve in a way that more stylized or surreal games do not suffer from.At least not to the same extent
November 3, 2025 at 2:58 PM
When did I ever state that no game should ever pursue photo realism? I just said it has the issue of appearing impressive for the time, but quickly losing its luster as techniques and technologies improve in a way that more stylized or surreal games do not suffer from.At least not to the same extent
Games we thought looked so impossibly real ten or twenty years ago now look incredibly dated. If you think it won't happen to the games of today, you haven't been paying attention.
November 3, 2025 at 2:46 PM
Games we thought looked so impossibly real ten or twenty years ago now look incredibly dated. If you think it won't happen to the games of today, you haven't been paying attention.
The issue with pursuing pure realism in a medium as reliant on current technology as video games is that the visuals will always age horribly once technology advances and games can render even more detailed characters and environments.
November 3, 2025 at 2:45 PM
The issue with pursuing pure realism in a medium as reliant on current technology as video games is that the visuals will always age horribly once technology advances and games can render even more detailed characters and environments.
I think the cohesion of the singular piece of work is more important than the cohesion of the franchise.
November 3, 2025 at 2:43 PM
I think the cohesion of the singular piece of work is more important than the cohesion of the franchise.
Like, Reach looks the way it does because there was clearly a want to be "more serious", more grounded in military aesthetics in a way that the previous games weren't. In a way I think it's a shame that its style has been co-opted as the unofficial HD Halo "look" over any other style.
November 3, 2025 at 2:17 PM
Like, Reach looks the way it does because there was clearly a want to be "more serious", more grounded in military aesthetics in a way that the previous games weren't. In a way I think it's a shame that its style has been co-opted as the unofficial HD Halo "look" over any other style.
As video games experience diminishing returns with the pursuit of photo-realism, I would generally prefer for us to branch out and try new visual styles. I think it's fine for different games in the same franchise to experiment with their visuals.
November 3, 2025 at 2:16 PM
As video games experience diminishing returns with the pursuit of photo-realism, I would generally prefer for us to branch out and try new visual styles. I think it's fine for different games in the same franchise to experiment with their visuals.
Of course the closest you hear about this in-game is from Halo 5, where the people of Meridian are pretty hostile to the main characters who are of course Spartans, and thus, symbols of UNSC power.
October 29, 2025 at 1:51 AM
Of course the closest you hear about this in-game is from Halo 5, where the people of Meridian are pretty hostile to the main characters who are of course Spartans, and thus, symbols of UNSC power.
We do have basically 15 years worth of post war material in the franchise. The gist is that the UNSC is severely weakened with several colonies able to go full independent in their absence, and said colonies typically hold resentment towards the UNSC for what they've done.
October 29, 2025 at 1:49 AM
We do have basically 15 years worth of post war material in the franchise. The gist is that the UNSC is severely weakened with several colonies able to go full independent in their absence, and said colonies typically hold resentment towards the UNSC for what they've done.
I mean Halsey does experience those consequences, but I think what's REALLY frustrating is that the government that hired her to do it does not.
October 29, 2025 at 1:47 AM
I mean Halsey does experience those consequences, but I think what's REALLY frustrating is that the government that hired her to do it does not.
Marty is the weak man creating hard times.
October 28, 2025 at 7:41 PM
Marty is the weak man creating hard times.
I think the biggest shame about Halo 3 is that it ends up undermining the idea that ALL Hunters actually joined the Elites when they split off from the Covenant, along with some Grunts. Granted I think Bungie realized you couldn't have a game purely made up of Brutes, Buggers, and Jackals.
October 28, 2025 at 2:18 PM
I think the biggest shame about Halo 3 is that it ends up undermining the idea that ALL Hunters actually joined the Elites when they split off from the Covenant, along with some Grunts. Granted I think Bungie realized you couldn't have a game purely made up of Brutes, Buggers, and Jackals.
Halo 3 largely exists to tie up the loose ends 2 left dangling after Bungie ran out of time to wrap everything up. So in effect, Halo 3 is just an extended finale that includes some dicking around on Earth before you venture to the Ark, and continue with where Halo 2 left off.
October 28, 2025 at 1:19 PM
Halo 3 largely exists to tie up the loose ends 2 left dangling after Bungie ran out of time to wrap everything up. So in effect, Halo 3 is just an extended finale that includes some dicking around on Earth before you venture to the Ark, and continue with where Halo 2 left off.
People often point to the sidelining of the Arbiter with nothing to really take its place as well as the loss of the franchise's lead writer, Joseph Staten, who was effectively temporarily exiled from the company following a big fight betweens devs after Halo 2.
October 28, 2025 at 1:18 PM
People often point to the sidelining of the Arbiter with nothing to really take its place as well as the loss of the franchise's lead writer, Joseph Staten, who was effectively temporarily exiled from the company following a big fight betweens devs after Halo 2.
Contact Harvest, a prequel written by the franchise's lead writer for CE, 2, and ODST, features a younger Sgt Johnson who is becoming increasingly disillusioned with the UNSC and his role in perpetuating their oppression of the colonies.
October 28, 2025 at 1:09 PM
Contact Harvest, a prequel written by the franchise's lead writer for CE, 2, and ODST, features a younger Sgt Johnson who is becoming increasingly disillusioned with the UNSC and his role in perpetuating their oppression of the colonies.
Especially when you venture into the books, and it is made abundantly clear that the series is not without its criticisms of imperialism or authoritarianism.
October 28, 2025 at 1:05 PM
Especially when you venture into the books, and it is made abundantly clear that the series is not without its criticisms of imperialism or authoritarianism.
Compared to something like Tom Clancy, where every Russian PoV character secretly pines to be American and military personnel are treated as simply a higher tier of being from the average person, I don't really think Halo is actually all that supportive of any of the things you claim.
October 28, 2025 at 1:01 PM
Compared to something like Tom Clancy, where every Russian PoV character secretly pines to be American and military personnel are treated as simply a higher tier of being from the average person, I don't really think Halo is actually all that supportive of any of the things you claim.
In CE at least, the Covenant's role in the story was to be usurped by the Flood and later Guilty Spark, the REAL threats.
Halo 2 then undermines the idea of the franchise being Humans vs Aliens when it elevates the Arbiter to co-main character status, and has the Elites ally with humans.
Halo 2 then undermines the idea of the franchise being Humans vs Aliens when it elevates the Arbiter to co-main character status, and has the Elites ally with humans.
October 28, 2025 at 12:58 PM
In CE at least, the Covenant's role in the story was to be usurped by the Flood and later Guilty Spark, the REAL threats.
Halo 2 then undermines the idea of the franchise being Humans vs Aliens when it elevates the Arbiter to co-main character status, and has the Elites ally with humans.
Halo 2 then undermines the idea of the franchise being Humans vs Aliens when it elevates the Arbiter to co-main character status, and has the Elites ally with humans.
Halo fans only think the Spartan Program was justified because Chief looked cool and they were 14 years old but even back in the first book, it's pretty clear that the UNSC was just a war-mongering fascist regime that had spent its entire history oppressing others and stomping out dissidents.
October 28, 2025 at 12:42 PM
Halo fans only think the Spartan Program was justified because Chief looked cool and they were 14 years old but even back in the first book, it's pretty clear that the UNSC was just a war-mongering fascist regime that had spent its entire history oppressing others and stomping out dissidents.
It doesn't, Dr. Halsey's (lady hired by the government to make child soldiers) arc in the books deals with her becoming disillusioned with her previous actions, and she eventually teaches Chief that it's wrong to sacrifice the innocent for the supposed "greater good".
October 28, 2025 at 12:38 PM
It doesn't, Dr. Halsey's (lady hired by the government to make child soldiers) arc in the books deals with her becoming disillusioned with her previous actions, and she eventually teaches Chief that it's wrong to sacrifice the innocent for the supposed "greater good".