The attorney general would be wise to read the words of the Supreme Court, which has repeatedly held that the "proudest boast" of America's free speech tradition is "freedom for the thought that we hate."

Karl Marx and Thorstein Veblen would have a lot to say about the modern leftism of elite America.

"What this event revealed, more than anything, is the tension between public persona and private reality. Mamdani campaigns on economic justice, police reform, and housing equity. But his family wealth, private armed security..."

www.economictimes.com/news/interna...

A classic...

www.youtube.com/watch?v=TjDE...

References

Harald means Ioannidis et al. Nature 2021, not Ioannidis et al., Nature 2020, which is about something else entirely.

Also, I referenced a paper Harald reviewed [Moreno-Mayar et al., Nature 2024], which replicated the Rapa Nui founder effect that we showed in the above 2022 preprint.

Anyway, the 2021 paper shows no evidence of significant later genetic contact. (See F4 stats, there's nothing to "correct" on those.)

The 2021 paper also noted that cultural contact btw islands had been proven by traded obsidian. Cultural contact is fascinating, but it is orthogonal to this debate.

As explained here arxiv.org/abs/2212.03197 the linked model does not show this. Also as shown here (replicated later in Nature 2024), Rapa Nui genetics is dominated by a founder effect, not later inter-island contact. Harald is a reviewer listed on that 2024 paper, so I take it he approved of that.

To be clear I am not arguing strongly for or against using race for college admissions, but all the Supreme Court justices appointed by a Democrat (three) did argue for, and I believe most supporters of Mamdani on here would argue for, and I believe he would too, so I'm reasoning in that framework.

Perhaps these two links are helpful to understand the US context. (Image from the 2023 US Supreme Court case, first link.)

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Student...

www.nytimes.com/2020/08/14/u...

It would be better, but the US is allergic to socialism (so income is out). Zip code is interesting; California is trying something like it (demographics of each high school), though more as a proxy for race than income, since its voters have barred it from using race directly via a referendum.

bsky.app/profile/alex...
Mamdani went to an elite Upper West Side private middle school and then tracked into a top NY magnet public high school. He understood identities well, and that Columbia considered race in admissions, as his father was a prof of Anthropology & African studies at Columbia.

bsky.app/profile/alex...

If you believe identity boxes should not be used for college admissions, then you are right.

If you believe they are important (and Mamdani is running on a platform that frequently emphasizes identity, so to him and to admissions officers at the time they were important), then this is fraud.

I would advise those US profs on here, who pretend not to understand what this is about due to their misplaced party loyalty, to come to east Oakland where I live, and I will show them.

The criticism I've seen on here seems directed at the NY Times for reporting a story that I suspect the Black community of New York, (who did not much support Mamdani), will find interesting. There is also criticism of the source, but whistleblowers take risks & will never be people w/ much to lose.

Mamdani's mother is a movie producer from India & his father is a prof from a colonial era family that came to British Africa from British India & like many other South Asian families (Freddie Mercury) were evicted from east Africa when it threw-off British associations. His father however returned.

Elon is more African than Mamdani, having spent a decade longer in his natal South Africa. Whatever your view on the attempt to include more Black students in university, those efforts are not for Elon Musk or Mamdani, (& imo should not be for Columbia profs children or wealthy private school kids).

The box said "Black or African American" because these are the two ways that community in the US identifies. Mamdani knows this, bc his father is a prof of African studies at Columbia. The objective is to include members of a community that suffered slavery and myriad later forms of discrimination.

As the 1st person from my public school to go to an Ivy League...exposed to these privileged (and to me at the time intimidating) kids from elite public & private schools & locales, with elite parents, many of whom ticked such boxes, who still sees this issue in faculty today, I'm very disturbed.