I agree (as author of the report). The issue is that when translation is discussed in the lit, the proposed purpose and context is a bit hand-wavy, and evidence base on how much extra PGIs ‘buy’ you given wealth of student data already available is lacking..I only found one study (that we cited)

Thank you - and looking forward to really digging into the ethical implications with you at the workshop!

Thanks for sharing, and for lending us your expertise and time!

Huge thanks to everyone who contributed and supported this work—especially
@nataliemichaux.bsky.social and Josh Hillman and the entire Nuffield Council on Bioethics team. Your insights and expertise were invaluable in shaping this report. Looking forward to discussions on its findings!