Grenzer
@grenzer.bsky.social
Bibliophile, scholar of history, philosophy, and literature. Sometimes talks about socialism.
Finally got around to reading the Wilson translation of the Odyssey, which happened to be included in volume A of the 4th edition of the Norton Anthology of World Literature that has languished on my shelf for a few years.
February 4, 2025 at 5:25 PM
Finally got around to reading the Wilson translation of the Odyssey, which happened to be included in volume A of the 4th edition of the Norton Anthology of World Literature that has languished on my shelf for a few years.
I don't really need an introduction in general, but it doesn't hurt to go back to the basics. The section on Poetry I found useful. That's probably my weak point.
January 30, 2025 at 6:30 PM
I don't really need an introduction in general, but it doesn't hurt to go back to the basics. The section on Poetry I found useful. That's probably my weak point.
Not really too impressed with Weil in general. I know this is more or less just an essay, but I've read other things. Her Platonism is a little ridiculous, but her earnestness is refreshing, one might say.
January 24, 2025 at 6:56 PM
Not really too impressed with Weil in general. I know this is more or less just an essay, but I've read other things. Her Platonism is a little ridiculous, but her earnestness is refreshing, one might say.
Back to the classics. I don't have too much to say on this one.
January 23, 2025 at 8:10 PM
Back to the classics. I don't have too much to say on this one.
As a work of history I think this book is seriously flawed. Losurdo betrays an immense ignorance of American history, and this is more of a propagandistic polemic than a serious reflection on history.
January 21, 2025 at 5:11 PM
As a work of history I think this book is seriously flawed. Losurdo betrays an immense ignorance of American history, and this is more of a propagandistic polemic than a serious reflection on history.
Short, but good. Another Hobsbawm classic.
January 20, 2025 at 3:11 PM
Short, but good. Another Hobsbawm classic.
Interested in reading more on this. The included essays were interesting, but it seems like they had a very narrow focus on England and Northern France. They're quite old as well. It would be interesting to see how this debate has evolved in the past 50 years.
January 17, 2025 at 1:14 PM
Interested in reading more on this. The included essays were interesting, but it seems like they had a very narrow focus on England and Northern France. They're quite old as well. It would be interesting to see how this debate has evolved in the past 50 years.
Been pretty lax about posting. Busy with real world duties, but I've still gotten a fair bit of reading done.
This is old, the contributions date from the early 60's, but it was still an interesting read. There was a bit more diversity of thought than I expected.
This is old, the contributions date from the early 60's, but it was still an interesting read. There was a bit more diversity of thought than I expected.
January 15, 2025 at 4:02 PM
Been pretty lax about posting. Busy with real world duties, but I've still gotten a fair bit of reading done.
This is old, the contributions date from the early 60's, but it was still an interesting read. There was a bit more diversity of thought than I expected.
This is old, the contributions date from the early 60's, but it was still an interesting read. There was a bit more diversity of thought than I expected.
For some reason Towles' books are something of a guilty pleasure. He's a pretty mediocre author and I find his overly affected bourgeois snobbery to be kind of unbearable at times. Yet I still have fun with these.
Enjoyed this more than the Lincoln Highway at any rate.
Enjoyed this more than the Lincoln Highway at any rate.
January 7, 2025 at 8:12 AM
For some reason Towles' books are something of a guilty pleasure. He's a pretty mediocre author and I find his overly affected bourgeois snobbery to be kind of unbearable at times. Yet I still have fun with these.
Enjoyed this more than the Lincoln Highway at any rate.
Enjoyed this more than the Lincoln Highway at any rate.
The more I see about this 'feudalism' discourse the more I'm reminded how the vast majority of marxists on twitter, despite their pretensions, are anti-intellectual philistines with a visceral hatred for any field of knowledge outside their own little bubble.
January 6, 2025 at 2:08 AM
The more I see about this 'feudalism' discourse the more I'm reminded how the vast majority of marxists on twitter, despite their pretensions, are anti-intellectual philistines with a visceral hatred for any field of knowledge outside their own little bubble.
Been a bit since I posted. Finished this yesterday.
Honestly, I wouldn't recommend it. Probably too much detail, and I think Orlando Figes covers the malignancy and incompetence of this disastrous figure far better and more concisely in his 'A People's Tragedy'.
Honestly, I wouldn't recommend it. Probably too much detail, and I think Orlando Figes covers the malignancy and incompetence of this disastrous figure far better and more concisely in his 'A People's Tragedy'.
January 5, 2025 at 9:47 PM
Been a bit since I posted. Finished this yesterday.
Honestly, I wouldn't recommend it. Probably too much detail, and I think Orlando Figes covers the malignancy and incompetence of this disastrous figure far better and more concisely in his 'A People's Tragedy'.
Honestly, I wouldn't recommend it. Probably too much detail, and I think Orlando Figes covers the malignancy and incompetence of this disastrous figure far better and more concisely in his 'A People's Tragedy'.
It's that time of year(to buy a bunch of books via annual holiday discount).
January 1, 2025 at 12:04 AM
It's that time of year(to buy a bunch of books via annual holiday discount).
Reposted by Grenzer
A superb essay about Thomas Mann’s Magic Mountain (and the Davos hotels which the sanatoriums on which it was based have become) by Samantha Rose Hill
theamericanscholar.org/under-a-spel...
theamericanscholar.org/under-a-spel...
Under a Spell Everlasting - The American Scholar
Thomas Mann’s Magic Mountain, published a century ago, tells of a world unable to free itself from the cataclysm of war
theamericanscholar.org
December 3, 2024 at 8:22 PM
A superb essay about Thomas Mann’s Magic Mountain (and the Davos hotels which the sanatoriums on which it was based have become) by Samantha Rose Hill
theamericanscholar.org/under-a-spel...
theamericanscholar.org/under-a-spel...
After all these years, finally got around to beginning Hobsbawm's legendary series. Haven't learned much new from this, but I've read a lot of history over the years. It really does synthesize a lot of information and I think this remains relevant.
December 3, 2024 at 3:23 PM
After all these years, finally got around to beginning Hobsbawm's legendary series. Haven't learned much new from this, but I've read a lot of history over the years. It really does synthesize a lot of information and I think this remains relevant.
Been busy with things, but I finally got around to finishing this. I've wanted to read a variety of things about the CIA and FBI, so I consider this a first step.
The book is quite comprehensive, but I think it is a little bottom heavy. The later period is covered more briefly.
The book is quite comprehensive, but I think it is a little bottom heavy. The later period is covered more briefly.
November 27, 2024 at 8:32 PM
Been busy with things, but I finally got around to finishing this. I've wanted to read a variety of things about the CIA and FBI, so I consider this a first step.
The book is quite comprehensive, but I think it is a little bottom heavy. The later period is covered more briefly.
The book is quite comprehensive, but I think it is a little bottom heavy. The later period is covered more briefly.
Reposted by Grenzer
Important to realize that when people are faced with events that challenge their worldview they generally double down on them rather than re-evaluating. Worldviews are very robust to, and even strengthened by, disconfirming experience. This is very bearish for mass politics
November 12, 2024 at 4:38 AM
Important to realize that when people are faced with events that challenge their worldview they generally double down on them rather than re-evaluating. Worldviews are very robust to, and even strengthened by, disconfirming experience. This is very bearish for mass politics
One thing about studying early US history that surprised me a bit is how much slavery permeated everything. We take it for granted that this was in the case in the south, but what about in the north? At the time of the revolution 20% of Boston households held enslaved people.
November 1, 2024 at 2:43 AM
One thing about studying early US history that surprised me a bit is how much slavery permeated everything. We take it for granted that this was in the case in the south, but what about in the north? At the time of the revolution 20% of Boston households held enslaved people.
One of the countless irritating things about liberals is that their screaming about 'America First' is a sham. Just bring up any aspect of American foreign policy and they all instantly turn into America Firsters.
October 31, 2024 at 6:43 PM
One of the countless irritating things about liberals is that their screaming about 'America First' is a sham. Just bring up any aspect of American foreign policy and they all instantly turn into America Firsters.
Mixed things up with a combo about both the American and French revolutions. The usual caveat with biographies applies.
This also reminds me about how much more I need to read about the French Revolution, and how woefully lacking English language historiography is on the subject.
This also reminds me about how much more I need to read about the French Revolution, and how woefully lacking English language historiography is on the subject.
October 31, 2024 at 6:36 PM
Mixed things up with a combo about both the American and French revolutions. The usual caveat with biographies applies.
This also reminds me about how much more I need to read about the French Revolution, and how woefully lacking English language historiography is on the subject.
This also reminds me about how much more I need to read about the French Revolution, and how woefully lacking English language historiography is on the subject.
Back to book posting, quite a backlog to post yet.
This one wasn't too interesting. Marginal figure in the greater scheme of things.
This one wasn't too interesting. Marginal figure in the greater scheme of things.
October 30, 2024 at 7:40 PM
Back to book posting, quite a backlog to post yet.
This one wasn't too interesting. Marginal figure in the greater scheme of things.
This one wasn't too interesting. Marginal figure in the greater scheme of things.
The way social media has shaped the left today is pretty unsatisfying. It encourages an orgy of commentary in a way that neither changes anything nor adds to any meaningful discussion or conversation.
Chatter for the sake of chatter. We're all guilty of that to some extent.
Chatter for the sake of chatter. We're all guilty of that to some extent.
October 27, 2024 at 6:28 PM
The way social media has shaped the left today is pretty unsatisfying. It encourages an orgy of commentary in a way that neither changes anything nor adds to any meaningful discussion or conversation.
Chatter for the sake of chatter. We're all guilty of that to some extent.
Chatter for the sake of chatter. We're all guilty of that to some extent.
Do people still use this? might start cross posting here.
October 25, 2024 at 6:27 PM
Do people still use this? might start cross posting here.
Disgusting to see Marxists applaud Bernie Sanders for saying that Israel should bomb Palestinian civilians, but moderately!
Same shit as always. Posture radical while lining up behind progressive liberals. Been that way for nearly 100 years now.
Same shit as always. Posture radical while lining up behind progressive liberals. Been that way for nearly 100 years now.
October 12, 2023 at 5:35 PM
Disgusting to see Marxists applaud Bernie Sanders for saying that Israel should bomb Palestinian civilians, but moderately!
Same shit as always. Posture radical while lining up behind progressive liberals. Been that way for nearly 100 years now.
Same shit as always. Posture radical while lining up behind progressive liberals. Been that way for nearly 100 years now.
It's interesting to see AOC use this tactic. She lacks the balls to endorse Israel directly, so she condemns those who oppose it.
The question is why? Apparently she worries about offending anti-zionists, even though they unconditionally vote Dem anyway. So what's the point?
The question is why? Apparently she worries about offending anti-zionists, even though they unconditionally vote Dem anyway. So what's the point?
October 11, 2023 at 10:39 PM
It's interesting to see AOC use this tactic. She lacks the balls to endorse Israel directly, so she condemns those who oppose it.
The question is why? Apparently she worries about offending anti-zionists, even though they unconditionally vote Dem anyway. So what's the point?
The question is why? Apparently she worries about offending anti-zionists, even though they unconditionally vote Dem anyway. So what's the point?
“I do not support Hamas, but rather the Palestinian people themselves!”
This is an absurdity given that Hamas is presently the institution through which national liberation finds expression.
There is no abstract will of the people that preexists its concrete embodiment.
This is an absurdity given that Hamas is presently the institution through which national liberation finds expression.
There is no abstract will of the people that preexists its concrete embodiment.
October 9, 2023 at 7:28 PM
“I do not support Hamas, but rather the Palestinian people themselves!”
This is an absurdity given that Hamas is presently the institution through which national liberation finds expression.
There is no abstract will of the people that preexists its concrete embodiment.
This is an absurdity given that Hamas is presently the institution through which national liberation finds expression.
There is no abstract will of the people that preexists its concrete embodiment.