Fiona Fidler
banner
fidlerfm.bsky.social
Fiona Fidler
@fidlerfm.bsky.social
Professor of History & Philosophy of Science (HPS) | Metascience | Improving Peer Review | Debates about statistical reform

Co-director of MetaMelb (an interdisciplinary metascience lab) at the University of Melbourne

pic: @replicats.bsky.social
Reposted by Fiona Fidler
🎉 50,000 listens! Thanks to everyone supporting The HPS Podcast, we're so grateful

We're proudly graduate-run— & work hard to provide episodes that reflect our community’s questions and passions, and the richness of ideas across HPS

Lots to come! Including some exciting developments for S6
(1/2)
October 24, 2025 at 2:43 AM
This episode is so great I hardly know where to start!The last ~15mins will be especially interesting to metascientists, including the most thoughtful plan for reforming scientific/research funding I think I’ve ever heard. Wow! #Metascience2025
What happens when the old contract between science and society no longer fits?

This week, Prof. Heather Douglas unpacks the legacy of the value-free ideal, examines research ethics & funding — and proposes a new social contract for science. This was an illuminating conversation.

Listen now! 🎧
S5 E4 - Heather Douglas on Rethinking Science’s Social Contract
The HPS Podcast - Conversations from History, Philosophy and Social Studies of Science · Episode
open.spotify.com
August 7, 2025 at 11:14 PM
Reposted by Fiona Fidler
Register now for the next joint @aimosinc.bsky.social @ausrepro.bsky.social webinar "Preventing statistical errors before publication" with Dr Michèle Nuijten and Dr Tom Hardwicke on Wed 27 Aug (4:00pm AEST).
@michelenuijten.bsky.social @tomhardwicke.bsky.social
qut.zoom.us/meeting/regi... 2/3
July 27, 2025 at 2:14 AM
Reposted by Fiona Fidler
Excited for Season 5 of the internationally award winning *The HPS Podcast* with new lead host @tespiteri.bsky.social!!

Congrats to Thomas - the season is set to be a cracker!!

Check out Episode 1 now in the usual podcast places - or via our website!!

#hps #philsci #sts #histSTM #metasci
July 18, 2025 at 12:35 AM
The HPS Podcast is back for 5th season!
July 27, 2025 at 11:03 PM
Reposted by Fiona Fidler
Metascience’s big tent 🏕️

Some reflections from @scurry.bsky.social and @jameswilsdon.bsky.social after hosting #Metascience2025 last week - as we all continue digesting the insights and engaging with the interesting post-conference discussions: www.researchprofessionalnews.com/rr-news-poli...
July 10, 2025 at 10:32 AM
Anyone had the experience of getting only one assessor’s report on an ARC DP?
July 3, 2025 at 9:58 PM
Expressions of interest in this Metascience PhD scholarship @unimelb are open now
June 27, 2025 at 2:35 PM
N=1 (hotel in Vienna). Sampling frame defined by distance from train. Stopping rule = price. No further address-related hypotheses were made prior to data collection. Post-hoc analysis may follow.
June 21, 2025 at 3:26 PM
Wondering where to publish your Metascience research?👇
The traditional publishing system for metaresearch is slow, costly, and siloed. MetaROR changes this by giving researchers a free, open platform to share their work and receive transparent peer reviews.

Read more: metaror.org
June 19, 2025 at 6:23 AM
Reposted by Fiona Fidler
"Bak-Coleman ‬and others say the reformers should have seen that their claims and concerns could be weaponized by antiscience movements, and done more to prevent that." I often write about sci reform & I'm genuinely curious, how do you "prevent that"?
www.science.org/content/arti...
Science’s reform movement should have seen Trump’s call for ‘gold standard science’ coming, critics say
Efforts to improve the rigor of research may have unwittingly handed the administration a way to attack science
www.science.org
June 12, 2025 at 2:14 PM
Reposted by Fiona Fidler
We are beyond excited to announce that we have won the prestigious 2024 BSHS Ayrton Prize for Digital Engagement!

From our 2023-2024 team - @samaragreenwood.bsky.social @cjcontarino.bsky.social @fidlerfm.bsky.social & Indigo Keel - thank you, it means so much

#hps #philsci #histSTM #sts 🧪
🎉 We’re excited to share that The HPS Podcast has won the 2024 BSHS Ayrton Prize! The podcast wowed us with its accessible, wide-ranging content and outstanding engagement. Congrats to the team! 🧠🎙️
👉 More info + links: www.bshs.org.uk/bshs-ayrton-...
June 13, 2025 at 12:10 AM
Me: maybe we should have a podcast or something?

HPS grad students:
🎉 We’re excited to share that The HPS Podcast has won the 2024 BSHS Ayrton Prize! The podcast wowed us with its accessible, wide-ranging content and outstanding engagement. Congrats to the team! 🧠🎙️
👉 More info + links: www.bshs.org.uk/bshs-ayrton-...
June 13, 2025 at 1:40 AM
Exciting new @unimelb PhD opportunity at the intersection of Metascience & Public Policy, funded by a Volkswagen Foundation ‘Researching Research’ grant. Best part is you’d get to work with the amazing Dr Kate Williams, expert in research evaluation and impact measurement
PhD Opportunity in Wider Societal Value of Research and Consequences of its Assessment: A multi-country and multi-method study (MultiSocVal) : Find an Expert : The University of Melbourne
<p> The overarching project is funded by a German Volkswagen Foundation Grant. It brings together international collaborators from four countries – University of Melbourne, Humboldt University, Stellenbosch University, SWPS University, and from a range of disciplines including public policy, sociology, data science, political science, applied linguistics, philosophy and science and technology studies. </p> <p> The PhD candidate will be supported by an overarching research team, including academics, postdocs, research associates and research assistants, spread across the four countries. </p> <p> The overall goals of the group are described below, although there is considerable scope for the PhD candidatee to focus their thesis on an aspect of this work that interests them. </p> <p> Many governments are showing a political commitment to research impact in their respective environments by investing in research evaluation initiatives at different scales. Often the initiatives are characterised by pragmatism, with little attention to underlying value judgements. This creates an urgent need for comparative work with a strong theoretical and empirical basis to study the effects of national evaluation initiatives around impact and societal value. The overall project will address this need through a multi-country and multi-method study of research evaluation initiatives in Germany, Australia, the United Kingdom, Poland and South Africa. Bringing together an international and interdisciplinary team, the project seeks to: </p> <p> (1) produce a comprehensive cross-national and cross-disciplinary overview of research systems with regard to scientific and societal value; </p> <p> (2) investigate what is considered worthwhile research within and between countries; </p> <p> (3) compare the effects of different research evaluation initiatives around impact on research practice in different countries; </p> <p> (4) develop an integrated conceptual framework of scientific and societal value to improve science policy and science practice; and </p> <p> (5) advance stakeholders’ understanding of the effects of research impact assessment for better future evaluation. </p> <p> <strong>About you</strong> </p> <p> We are looking for a candidate with a strong academic background in a relevant discipline such as public policy, sociology, political science, science and technology studies, or a related field. The candidate will be intellectually curious and motivated by critical questions about the role of research in society. Ideally, the candidate will bring an interest in the changing landscape of research governance, including how ideas of value, worth, and impact are shaped and operationalised across national science systems. </p> <p> We welcome applicants with experience in qualitative, quantitative, or mixed-methods research. An enthusiasm for learning new methods – including bibliometric or computational text analysis, survey design, or innovative qualitative analysis – will be an advantage. The candidate will thrive in interdisciplinary and collaborative environments and be keen to contribute to an international research team spanning multiple countries and disciplinary traditions. Strong written and verbal communication skills, along with the ability to work independently and manage a sustained research project, are essential. </p> <p> This project offers considerable scope for the PhD candidate to shape their own research focus within the broader program, and would suit someone interested in contributing to both theoretical and practical understandings of how research is evaluated and governed in contemporary societies. </p> <p> <strong>Eligibility</strong> </p> <p> Domestic and International applicants may apply. You must meet the entry requirements for the <a href="https://handbook.unimelb.edu.au/courses/dr-philart">Doctor of Philosophy – Arts at the University of Melbourne (link attached)</a> including English language requirements and demonstrate excellent capacity and potential for research. </p> <p> As the successful candidate, You will demonstrae: </p> <ul> <li>An academic background in the field of sociology (of culture/science or related area), STS, library and information science, or public policy/research governance </li> <li>A relevant undergraduate and/or postgraduate degree with an average that equivalent to a H1 (80%) at the University of Melbourne, including H1 results in the Honours or Master’s thesis component; and </li> <li>Experience with qualitative analysis or quantitative analysis in the above fields </li> <li>The ability to write research reports or other publications to a publishable standard (even if not published to date) </li> <li>capability to manage projects effectively, meet deadlines and achieve outcomes within a specified timeframes. </li> </ul> <p> <strong>How to submit an expression of interest</strong> </p> <p> Please submit your expression of interest (EOI) via the ‘Submit Expression of Interest’ button by 15 July 2025. </p> <p> Your EOI must include: </p> <ul> <li>A short description of how the project aligns with your interest and experience, an overview of how your might approach the project goals, and an outline of three relevant references from the literature with a description of how they relate to the project </li> <li>A CV that highlights your relevant academic achievements and any relevant professional experience including the names of two academic referees. </li> <li>Higher education academic transcripts that give detailed information of the individual marks received in your university-level qualifications to date </li> <li>An example of your written academic work (e.g. Honours or masters thesis or peer-reviewed journal article) </li> </ul> <p> For more information about our PhD program and application process, please visit <a href="https://arts.unimelb.edu.au/study/graduate-research"><strong>this website</strong></a>. </p>
findanexpert.unimelb.edu.au
June 13, 2025 at 1:32 AM
Reposted by Fiona Fidler
Discuss with us the past, present, and future of scientific reform during #SIPS2025!

Join us for the exciting Keynote Panel with @simine.com-BSky @eikofried.bsky.social @fidlerfm.bsky.social @syeducation.bsky.social and Eric-Jan Wagenmakers.

Register here buff.ly/WUIXiqK
#PsychPsySky
May 30, 2025 at 12:02 PM
Reposted by Fiona Fidler
Excited to announce this upcoming worshop about trust and credibility in psychology. Registration deadline is June 5 (tomorrow), but please note that this is an in-person event. So register only if you know that you will be able to attend
#philsi #metascience #psychology, #sts
SOCRATES Workshop: Trust and Credibility in the Psychological Sciences – Beyond Replication
www.socrates.uni-hannover.de
June 4, 2025 at 10:23 AM
Reposted by Fiona Fidler
Hey SIPS folks, we want to run a small repliCATS pilot on Day 0 (24 June) in Budapest to get feedback on our latest project! Join @fidlerfm.bsky.social & @fallonmody.bsky.social for a 2-hour session, with catered lunch + 50 euro visa card. More details here: forms.gle/Z7p7PqA5vqpC...
May 29, 2025 at 3:54 AM
Here is a quick lesson in objectivity in science, and why diversity is important to its maintenance. Plus a fascinating case study! @samaragreenwood.bsky.social
How feminism changed primatology - ABC listen
For decades, primatologists believed that primate societies were structured around aggressive alpha males - until a remarkable push from feminist scientists in the 1960s and 70s changed the narrative....
www.abc.net.au
May 9, 2025 at 3:34 AM
Reposted by Fiona Fidler
A huge welcome to our new host for 2025 Thomas Spiteri @tespiteri.bsky.social!

Word is some excellent interviews are coming your way very soon... #hps #philsci #histstm #sts
So close! By the way... there's a new season in the works -- with some very, very exciting guests. Stay tuned.

Oh, and now's a good time to mention I'll be jumping in as the host for 2025! ;)
Help us break 10K!

We are just 19 away from reaching a milestone 10,000 follows. If you haven't already joined our wonderful community of people & organisations interested in historical, philosophical & sociological perspectives on science, the time is NOW :)

#hps #histSTM #philsci
April 23, 2025 at 9:38 AM
Reposted by Fiona Fidler
The ARC Board has proposed a major shake-up of the National Competitive Grants Program ▶️ www.arc.gov.au/engage-us/co...

I've only skimmed so far, but they propose reducing 13 grant schemes to 6, with intent & scope in the table👇

Submissions are being accepted in response until 13 April. Get to it!
February 25, 2025 at 3:46 AM
Reposted by Fiona Fidler
🧪The PRIMeR group is offering a research scholarship on metaresearch/ publication integrity. Applicants must be eligible to enrol as a domestic student at the University of Sydney (no international applicants, sorry)
Applications close on 19 December 2024
Details: www.sydney.edu.au/scholarships...
Research Scholarship in Literature Reviews in Molecular Cancer Research
Up to $127,320 research scholarship for a PhD student to investigate problematic literature reviews in molecular cancer research.
www.sydney.edu.au
November 28, 2024 at 10:10 PM
Reposted by Fiona Fidler
But you saw in the first graph that the success rate continued to decline sharply. It’s now just 13%!

This year, that was driven by the 2-stage process. In previous years the driver was low funding of the scheme.
November 26, 2024 at 10:59 PM
Reposted by Fiona Fidler
Yesterday was an improvement for Discovery Projects.

An extra ~$110 million was invested compared to last year (which was a low point).

It replaces rapid loss in last 2 years & aligns investment with the last 12 years (adjusted for inflation).

Not enough, but a start!
November 26, 2024 at 10:59 PM
Read back to the start!
And now for the announcement:
While many of our plans for the award funds will take time to implement, one can start immediately.
To thank our users and encourage scientific debate, we’re introducing $1,000 rewards for selected PubPeer comments!
Yes students and postdocs you read that right: $1000
November 27, 2024 at 8:49 AM
Read all the way to the end!
PubPeer has received the 2024 Einstein Foundation Award. This recognition celebrates the contributions of our community to scientific discourse. award.einsteinfoundation.de/award-winner...
This award provides a financial boost that we’re reinvesting back into the platform and its users. See below:
PubPeer – Einstein Foundation Award
award.einsteinfoundation.de
November 27, 2024 at 8:49 AM