And despite messing up in her life, it's the constant good you see in catie through your photos carrot that charmed catie to you

You make her better
You keep her honest
She wants to keep growing more with you

You make catie like herself
And that makes her love and appreciate you

But you see catie!

Its that dumb simple honesty to your character is why carrot is smitten by you

She loves when you're honest

Hugs