[THIS USER HAS SPENT 23 YEARS STRANDED ON WHOPPER WORLD IN THE FAR REACHES OF THE BURGER SYSTEM]
Comparing this to the new graphic novels is kinda rough because those are so much better, but this one wasn't that bad. It has a distinctly different plot and setting than most books in the series, which is a plus and made it enjoyable enough to read.
5/10
Comparing this to the new graphic novels is kinda rough because those are so much better, but this one wasn't that bad. It has a distinctly different plot and setting than most books in the series, which is a plus and made it enjoyable enough to read.
5/10
It's, to put it simply, not good, poorly paced, and full of filler. But it's fun to read about cats, and the references to the events of the last arc are cool. I don't think they handled Jaypaw's blindness very well but he was also the most interesting protag.
3/10. i guess
It's, to put it simply, not good, poorly paced, and full of filler. But it's fun to read about cats, and the references to the events of the last arc are cool. I don't think they handled Jaypaw's blindness very well but he was also the most interesting protag.
3/10. i guess
Maybe even better than the first one? The art is even more colorful and expressive. Adapts the wonkier middle books in the arc (Forest of Secrets and Rising Storm) surprisingly effectively, adapting some big moments especially well.
9/10
Maybe even better than the first one? The art is even more colorful and expressive. Adapts the wonkier middle books in the arc (Forest of Secrets and Rising Storm) surprisingly effectively, adapting some big moments especially well.
9/10
Surprisingly good, especially for Warrior Cats. The art and character designs are cute and expressive, while the plot is adapted wonderfully. Slightly held back by 2/3 being an adaption of Into the Wild with 1/3 being Fire and Ice (a much worse book)
8/10?
Surprisingly good, especially for Warrior Cats. The art and character designs are cute and expressive, while the plot is adapted wonderfully. Slightly held back by 2/3 being an adaption of Into the Wild with 1/3 being Fire and Ice (a much worse book)
8/10?