Colin Murray
banner
colinmurray.bsky.social
Colin Murray
@colinmurray.bsky.social

Professor of Law & Democracy @newcastleuni.bsky.social

Constitutional Law | Human Rights | Brexit | Devolution | Political Violence | Colonialism | Other Assorted Dourness

He/Him

Political science 58%
Law 17%
Pinned
A new Explainer out from @aoifemod.bsky.social and me detailing the UK's ECHR commitments under the 1998 Agreement in response to recent speculation. It is short, because there is very little to say - the UK's obligations are evident on the B/GFA's plain text:

caj.org.uk/wp-content/u...

This, from @saraita101.bsky.social, is not going to brighten up this dreichest of days, but it does confront the immediate issue facing NI that we're locked in a recrimination cycle, and the Unionist parties who have the most to lose from it are pushing it hardest:

www.irishnews.com/opinion/sara...
Sarah Creighton: As the DUP declines to send anyone to President Connolly in Dublin, the scary question is: do we even want reconciliation here?
Maybe we like the cycle of outrage and hurt. It’s comfortable and it’s all we know
www.irishnews.com

Reposted by Rory O’Connell

The Bingham Centre report on UK counter-terrorism law has landed. Apply its findings to anything from the Kneecap prosecution to the banning of Palestine Action and you find just how draconian UK counter-terrorism law is, and the extent of necessary reform:

binghamcentre.biicl.org/documents/22...

Reposted by Colin Murray

Trump rumoured to be consulting Albert Reynolds using a Oui Ja Board for advice on foreign leaders using defamation law against UK media...

Reposted by Colin Murray

The Ivan Yates interview is hilarious in its refusal to even contemplate the key ethics issue. Media coaches can maintain the confidentiality of clients. The problem was Yates' choice to then engage in campaign media as a commentator, not a paid adviser to one campaign.

www.rte.ie/news/politic...

As Alan Rusbridger points out, the cabal of "news" organisations attacking the BBC have far greater shortcomings and are already delighted to skew our information environment:

www.prospectmagazine.co.uk/ideas/media/...

This as not simply populism, it's an extreme assault on public institutions and structures. The last week has been about the BBC, but comes alongside mounting attacks on judicial independence/the European Court of Human Rights. Treating each issue in isolation will see them killed off one by one.
What you’re witnessing is a populist assault on the BBC.

This is not an institutional scandal in any meaningful sense of the word. It is an attack on public service broadcasting.

iandunt.substack.com/p/extra-edit...
What you’re witnessing is a populist assault on the BBC.

This is not an institutional scandal in any meaningful sense of the word. It is an attack on public service broadcasting.

iandunt.substack.com/p/extra-edit...
Incredible that Robbie Gibb - most influential person on BBC board by many accounts and from journalists I speak in BBC - was involved in setting up GB News.

GB News of course has breached Ofcom rules on *multiple* occasions - no sign of resignations though

www.theguardian.com/environment/...
‘Enforced veganism’: Ofcom lets GB News flout accuracy rules, say climate campaigners
Exclusive: Regulator has received 1,221 complaints about UK broadcasters since 2020 but found no breaches of its code
www.theguardian.com

Whereas we really do, and our rate of firsts would be vanishingly small without it...

You see algorithm in the title here and you think, I can't cope with big tech anymore, but upping this WonkHE piece as my weekend read. All HE institutions in the UK have their own rules on how degree outcomes are calculated & this really impacts on degree equivalence:

share.google/OCpk1FP8AfCM...
Algorithms aren't the problem. It's the classification system they support
With England's regulator cracking down on “flexible” degree algorithms, Jim Dickinson argues that what’s at stake isn’t just grade inflation, but how universities define student success
share.google

Reposted by Rory O’Connell

Rule of law says what now (Ireland edition)?
The Government's new stated aim is to make it so unattractive for lawyers to take good cases against the State that they will stop. Not bad cases. Good ones. Successful ones. This new rule only applies if you *win* your case. Doesn't that worry anyone slightly?

m.independent.ie/irish-news/o...
Objectors will be on the hook to pay six-figure legal costs under judicial reviews clampdown
Objectors will have to foot six-figure legal bills for successful judicial review cases in a new move being brought to the Cabinet to speed up the supply of infrastructure and housing.
m.independent.ie

Reposted by Colin Murray

The Government's new stated aim is to make it so unattractive for lawyers to take good cases against the State that they will stop. Not bad cases. Good ones. Successful ones. This new rule only applies if you *win* your case. Doesn't that worry anyone slightly?

m.independent.ie/irish-news/o...
Objectors will be on the hook to pay six-figure legal costs under judicial reviews clampdown
Objectors will have to foot six-figure legal bills for successful judicial review cases in a new move being brought to the Cabinet to speed up the supply of infrastructure and housing.
m.independent.ie

Reposted by Colin Murray

Maybe there was an era when apologies helped. Now it’ll just pivot the story to “so you admit you got this wrong, who’s to blame and why haven’t they resigned yet?”

If someone resigns, it’ll be “why didn’t their boss resign too?”, and so on.

The game has changed. Institutions need to catch up.

Give me a void and I'll scream into it.

The reality is that Brexit is a cold place full of tough choices when next door to the EU as a mega trading bloc. Either try to shut yourself off as much as possible, as the Tories did, suffering checks & dislocation, or you'll have to pay (£££) to pig-a-back on EU rules:

www.ft.com/content/8963...

Reposted by Colin Murray

If gave you €1 every second since you were born:

You would have €1 million within a week and a half.

You would have €1 billion by 32.

You would never have €1 trillion. Generations upon generations after you would not reach €1 trillion. Because it would take over 31,700 years to reach €1 trillion.
Extraordinary story from @sheffieldtribune.bsky.social: A London lawyer bought hundreds of Sheffield freeholds. Then the ‘very aggressive’ letters arrived.

One woman: “It broke my heart, that was my savings towards a new car...He has just wiped me out.”

www.sheffieldtribune.co.uk/a-london-law...
A London lawyer bought hundreds of Sheffield freeholds. Then the ‘very aggressive’ letters arrived
Exclusive: The Tribune can reveal that Andrew Milne has threatened leaseholders with high court action. It ‘broke my heart’ one woman says
www.sheffieldtribune.co.uk

Everyone gets their own article in The Telegraph, this week and any week, provided they're willing to hail the transformative benefits of leaving the ECHR, but deny the reality that parts of the UK think very little of the quality of British justice shorn of international oversight.
Between 11am and 1pm tomorrow, join Robert Spano, Jens Elo Peters Rytter, @colmocinneide.bsky.social and @profveronika.bsky.social to discuss the future of the European Convention on Human Rights, both in Europe and the UK.

Sign up to attend this in-person event at @laws.ucl.ac.uk 👇
The Future of the ECHR - In Europe and UK
Organised by the Human Rights Institute and the Global Centre for Democratic Constitutionalism.
www.ucl.ac.uk

The NIHRC has repeatedly had to fight in the courts to be able to do its job. If the Chief Commissioner can't raise rights issues in press interviews, this undermines its (statutory) public education role. This is a key GFA institution - it must not be muzzled:

www.irishnews.com/news/norther...
Shankill bomb victim’s brother in court challenge against human rights chief’s comments
Gary Murray tackling Alyson Kilpatrick after she questioned objectivity of senior figures in legacy investigations body
www.irishnews.com

Reposted by Michelle Everson

I've a new paper out in the Discrimination Law Association's Briefings on the distinct Windsor Framework's rights/equality arrangements applicable to Northern Ireland law, which give ongoing significance of a broad sweep of EU protections even after Brexit:

discriminationlaw.org.uk/assets/docum...

Definitely could, sorry for parsing in the post.

The protections for philosophical belief under the Equality Act really don't play nicely with police discretion to stop and search those suspected of involvement in political violence under the Terrorism Act. A likely AG Reference coming:

news.sky.com/story/tommy-...
Tommy Robinson found not guilty of terror offence for failing to give police access to his phone at Channel Tunnel
Police had demanded access to his iPhone under Schedule 7 of the Terrorism Act
news.sky.com

Sometimes getting a random like or comment on a year+ old post reminds me of what BlueSky was like when there were about five of us (okay, a million) of us here, and it felt like posting into the void. Reupping for posterity, in case you missed it first time ...
At the Nobel Prize Museum in Stockholm and kinda mortified for David Trimble for the summary they give for his peace prize. It's like the reference no one really wanted to write. What about his stance was he known for? Best left unsaid.

Reposted by Colin Murray

Very insistent, is The Times leader today, that the Supreme Court ruling is clear. But even it can't agree what the ruling means.

Snips from The Times on 4/11/25, 12/9/25 and 26/9/25.

The (adult) person next to me on a flight is engrossed in Miracle on 34th Street. Reader, I'm so not in this festive zone that I'm torn between envy and incredulity. Come back to me in a month...
a man with a beard and a hat is talking to another man .
ALT: a man with a beard and a hat is talking to another man .
media.tenor.com

When people talk about the Overton Window shifting, this sounds like a magical process. But really it means that the space for public debate is being actively constrained by publications sacking journalists who provided divergent (progressive) accounts of what's going on in the world...
I was laid off from Teen Vogue today along with multiple other staffers, and today is my last day.

certainly more to come from me when the dust has settled more, but to my knowledge, after today, there will be no politics staffers at Teen Vogue.

The PSNI is presenting a defence to the data breach case that's basically "we can't afford a remedy". But data protection rights derive from EU law, and affected officers could invoked the EU Charter's right to effective remedy under Art 2 WF. Fun to come:

www.irishtimes.com/crime-law/co...